Monday, May 9, 2011

Seven Rare Indus Signs of Seven Strokes


The most common symbol in the Indus script is the POT, or "flying U."  But not every Indus “pot” has “F” shaped prongs protruding from the sides.  Those “U” (and “V”) shapes that have some other element adorning the tops are still “pots” in my terminology.  The first I will discuss in this post is ONE IN CHEVRON TOPPED POT (VII 47).  A small chevron sits atop each “arm” of the basic “U” shape, while a short vertical stands between them.  Only Wells lists this sign (W34), noting it to be a singleton (MacKay XCIII 3).  I have not seen it since it does not appear in the first two volumes of the Corpus of Indus Seals and Inscriptions, but I include in the list nonetheless.

A second, equally obscure symbol is TRI-FORK AND BUD TOPPED POT (VII 48).  In this case, the left “arm” of the basic “U” is topped with the three-part division I term a “tri-fork” (also known as a trident).  The right “arm takes the form of the BUD symbol.  This asymmetrical sign appears only in the list prepared by Koskenniemi and Parpola (KP106).
Detail from seal M-777 with inscription: FOOTED STOOL / PINCH /
BELTED FISH UNDER CHEVRON / SPEAR // TABLE BETWEEN CIRCLES.

The third sign is TABLE BETWEEN CIRCLES (VII 49).  The “table” element is the version with one short “leg” and a second “long” one discussed among the three-stroke signs (III 6).  Sign VII 49 appears only in Wells (W372), noted as another singleton, although it closely resembles other symbols.  The five-stroke POST BETWEEN CIRCLES (V 48) is essentially the same except that a single vertical separates the circles rather than a “table.”  Similarly, BARBELL ON POST (VI 60) also includes two circles, this time separated (or joined) by a vertical plus a very short horizontal.  If one prefers to group these three signs together, one could term them all DIVIDED CIRCLES, designating the type of central divider either by name or by letter.  Thus, one might consider a variant “A” to be DIVIDED CIRCLES WITH POST, variant “B” to be DIVIDED CIRCLES WITH POST AND BAR, and variant “C” to be DIVIDED CIRCLES WITH TABLE.  If this method of grouping is preferred, then VII 49 A is a singleton from Chanhujo daro, VII 49 B occurs three times at Mohenjo daro according to Wells (although I find six from Mohenjo daro and perhaps eight from Harappa), and VII 49 C is another singleton from Mohenjo daro (M-777).

Only Luwian hieroglyphs provide a close analogy to these variations on a theme.  The glyph includes two small circles divided by an upside-down “L” shape.  This is a phonetic symbol representing the syllable wa or wi.  It is considerably more common in Luwian than in the Indus script.

The only other parallel to this that I have observed occurs in the art of Texas.  Here, two circles appear on either side of a central vertical line (Newcomb and Kirkland 1996: 107, Pl. 68, no. 24).  However, these marks are only part of a far more complex motif on a painted pebble.  Each circle contains a dot and there are diagonal elements above (or are they below?) these dotted circles.  The whole thing gives an impression of a face or mask, though without an obvious mouth.
Seal Ad-t with inscription: STACKED THREE / OVERLAPPING CIRCLES / POT//
BARBELL BETWEEN SLASHES / ANKH.

The next sign is VII 50, BARBELL BETWEEN SLASHES, also known as KP348 and W385, though not found in Fairservis.  The “barbell” element occurs independently in two published lists (KP347 and Fs K-11), but this existence is rather problematic.  Although both Fairservis and the Koskenniemi and Parpola team depict the BARBELL as two circles joined by a clear and obvious horizontal line of some length, I have only seen it in this form as part of a ligature.  Two circles are joined by a very short horizontal at their bases at Kalibangan (K-43).  A BARBELL may occur on the almost illegible M-1376, though this may be nothing but DOUBLE CIRCLES (or DOUBLE CIRCLED DOTS).  A caged BARBELL appears at Lothal (L-96).  But that ligature is a nine-stroke symbol.  Then there is the BARBELL BETWEEN SLASHES (more accurately, between a slash and a backslash).  This is a singleton from Allahdino (Ad-6).

The “barbell” motif is common in the rock art of North America, where it appears in various forms.  In Texas there are asymmetrical instances, where one circle is larger than the other, more symmetrical instances where the circles contain dots, fancier outlined versions, and even occurrences that are outlined and contain dots plus have assorted dots around them as if for added emphasis (Newcomb and Kirkland 1996: 100-104, Pl. 56-63, Pl. 56 nos. 1 and 2, Pl. 57, Pl. 60, Pl. 62, and Pl. 63).  In the Nevada collection there are 130 occurrences of connected circles (e.g., Heizer and Baumhoff 1984: 136, fig. 73 e).  Something like a “barbell” appears in proto-cuneiform as NUNUZ, “egg(s), offspring; female, woman”; it occurs again in proto-Elamite (M309~a and M371).  Barbell-like elements even appear among the enigmatic symbols carved on Pictish monuments.  But nowhere else does such a motif occur regularly between two leaning posts as in Indus sign VII 50.
Detail from seal M-115 with inscription (over unicorn): HAIRY DUCK HEAD / PANTS / BI-QUOTES //
CIRCLED TRI-FORK / HAIRY HUNCHBACK / LOOP ARMED MAN HOLDING SLASH /
QUOTES IN OVERLAPPING CIRCLES / TRI-FORK.

The next sign is VII 51, QUOTES IN OVERLAPPING CIRCLES.  Wells alone lists this form (W355).  He finds five occurrences, four of them from Mohenjo daro and one from Lothal.  Symbols that include an overlap are not frequent around the world, but a few do occur.  I mentioned a few of these previously, in the post on the simpler sign OVERLAPPING CIRCLES.  These parallels include the Old Chinese yu2, “to pass from hand to hand, to hand down, to give, communication, connexion” (Wieger 1965: 236).  This is a quite distant parallel, however, since the basic elements are stacked triangles, the apex of the upper one overlapping the apex of the lower.  A curving stroke is added at the base of the lower triangle.  The placement of this last stroke is significant, too.  If it appears at the top instead of at the bottom of the character, the word is changed to huan4, “fraud, deceiving, false” (1965: 237).

Among the African Adinkra symbols, there are overlapping diamonds.  The name for this symbol is epa, meaning “handcuffs” (Willis 1998: 100).  This represents law and justice, not surprisingly.  There is also a symbol comprising two elements overlapping that are more difficult to describe – something like a circle with two posts protruding at the top and bottom.  The name for this unusual symbol is nyansapo, “wisdom knot,” and it symbolizes wisdom, ingenuity, intelligence, and patience (1998: 164).  And while there may be no overlapping circles in North American rock art, there is a motif of a circle divided by a horizontal line, with a dot in each segment (Newcomb and Kirkland 1996: 101, Pl. 57).
Bar seal M-354 with inscription: MAN HOLDING DEE-SLASH / BACK CEE & CEE / BI-QUOTES //
CAGED FISH UNDER CHEVRON / SLASHES IN OVERLAPPING CIRCLES / QUINT-FORK /
CUP ON THREE PRONGS UNDER CHEVRON / POT.

The following Indus sign may well be a variant of this last one: SLASHES IN OVERLAPPING CIRCLES (VII 52).  It appears elsewhere as KP352 and W347, though not in Fairservis.  Wells notes 17 occurrences, 13 of them from Mohenjo daro, three from Harappa, and one from Lothal (eight from outside the Corpus).

The same analogs might be cited for this sign as for the previous one.  In addition, we may note the use of two overlapping circles – with additional ornamentation – to represent bracelets in Tibetan Buddhist art (Bryant 1992: 163).  This symbol appears as part of a naming ceremony for young student monks in a monastery.

Our final sign is VII 53, OVERLAPPING CIRCLES WITH ATTACHED TRI-FORK, also known as KP351 and W387.  This is another sign that I have not seen, since, as Wells indicates, it is a singleton not found in the Corpus (MacKay XCIII 2).  In this symbol, the overlapping elements have no inner markings, but on one side a trident protrudes.  Koskenniemi and Parpola’s list show the trident as a “Y” shape in which the central vertical continues up between the top “arms.”  Wells, on the other hand, shows the trident as a post to which three prongs are attached, rather like a long-stemmed letter “E.”  Since I cannot view the actual symbol, I do not know which is more correct.  And in any case, I see nothing comparable among the signs of other scripts, proto-scripts, and symbol systems.  However, this may be another instance of Indus-style gunification, the non-standardized modification of a standard sign in order to convey specific information, a process clearly used in proto-cuneiform and proto-Elamite.  The attached “tri-fork” appears relatively frequently in the Indus script even if this particular instance is rare.



SOURCES

(I include here only my basic sources and a few that I have acquired recently.)

Bryant, Barry. 1992. The Wheel of Time Sand Mandala: Visual Scripture of Tibetan Buddhism. Ithaca, New York: Snow Lion Publications.

Çambel, Halet. 1999. Corpus of Hieroglyphic Inscriptions. Vol. II. Karatepe-Aslantaş. New York: Walter de Gruyter.

Damerow, Peter and Robert Englund. 1989. The Proto-Elamite Texts from Tepe Yahya. Cambridge: Harvard University.

Fairservis, Walter. 1992. The Harappan Civilization and its Writing: A Model for the Decipherment of the Indus Script. Leiden: E.J. Brill.

Gardiner, Sir Alan. 1976. Egyptian Grammar. Oxford: Griffith Institute and Ashmolean Museum.

Heizer, Robert F. and Martin A. Baumhoff. 1984. Prehistoric Rock Art of Nevada and Eastern California. Berkeley: University of California.

Joshi, Jagat Pati and Asko Parpola. 1987. Corpus of Indus Seals and Inscriptions. 1. Collections in India. Helsinki: Suomalainen Tiedeakatemia.

Koskenniemi, Kimmo and Asko Parpola. 1982. A Concordance to the Texts in the Indus Script. Department of Asian and African Studies, University of Helsinki.

LeQuellec, Jean-Loic. 2004. Rock Art in Africa: Mythology and Legend. Translator, Paul Bahn. Paris: Flammarion.

Masson, V.M. 1988. Altyn-Depe. Translator, Henry N. Michael. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania.

Newcomb, Jr., W.W. and H. Kirkland. 1996. The Rock Art of Texas Indians. Austin: University of Texas.

Shah, Sayid Ghulam Mustafa and Asko Parpola. 1991. Corpus of Indus Seals and Inscriptions. 2. Collections in Pakistan. Helsinki: Suomalainen Tiedeakatemia.

Wells, Bryan. 1998. An Introduction to Indus Writing: A Thesis. University of Calgary. www.collectionscanada.gc.ca/obj/s4/f2/dsk2/ftp03/MQ31309.pdf

Wieger, Dr. L. 1965. Chinese Characters. Dover: New York.

Willis, W. Bruce. 1998. The Adinkra Dictionary: A Visual Primer on The Language of Adinkra. Washington, D.C.: The Pyramid Complex.

Websites:

Old Europe


Cretan hieroglyphs:


South American rock art:


Alpine rock art:


African rock art:


Proto-cuneiform:


Proto-Elamite:
http://cdli.ucla.edu/wiki/doku.php/linear-elamite

Six Indus Signs of Seven Strokes Each

Detail from seal M-113 with inscription: CEE BOAT / PINCH / POTTED ONE /
OVERLAPPING CIRCLES / TWO POSTS / POT (the 3rd is today's most common sign).

Sign VII 41 (the forty-first symbol comprising seven strokes) is what I term EARPHONES ON BI-FORK.  It is also known as KP345 (more accurately described as a nine-stroke sign), W74, and Fs K-9.  Fairservis identifies this symbol as weighing scales, defining it as “to weigh” (or as a substantive).  Wells finds three of the symbol, but each is distinct in form.  His “a” has a straight-stemmed “Y” shape at the bottom, “b” also does but the “V” shape at the top is tilted to the right, and “c” has a bent stem.  All three come from Mohenjo daro, so the differences do not appear to be geographical.
Seal M-1159 with inscription: TWO POSTS / EARPHONES ON BI-FORK (VII 41 B) / BI-QUOTES //
TWO POSTS / FISH / CAGED FISH (note that BI-FORK tilts to the left in 2nd symbol).


If the symbol actually represents weighing scales, we might compare the Egyptian hieroglyph U38 defined by Gardiner as a balance.  This rather different symbol acts as an ideograph or determinative in mh3t, “balance” (there should be a scoop beneath the “h”).  Another glyph has the form of the “earphones” element of the Indus sign, but this part is rotated 90 degrees (V13).  This glyph represents a rope for tethering animals and is used as a phonetic symbol for t (the underlined letter is traditionally pronounced “ch” in Egyptology, although that probably is not what the Egyptians themselves said).  This glyph is combined with the little walking legs element (D54) to make V15.  The combination serves to represent the word iti, “to seize.”
Detail from seal M-675 with inscription over unicorn:
TWO POSTS / EARPHONES ON BI-FORK (VII 41 C) / BI-QUOTES //
FISH UNDER CHEVRON / BACKSLASH IN FISH / CUPPED POST (OR SPOON) / THREE POSTS /
CAGED CIRCLED TRI-FORK / BUGS ON LEAF / POT (note curve of BI-FORK stem).
Now, the Indus EARPHONES appear as a distinct sign also (V49, also known as KP344 and W75).  This element occurs three times, including once at Mohenjo daro.  The other element, BI-FORK, has an independent existence (III 12) too, although only as a singleton from Lohumjo daro.  We may interpret EARPHONES ON BI-FORK as a composite symbol for this reason, i.e., as a ligature composed of two simpler signs.  Egyptian glyph V15, a composite symbol made up of two simpler glyphs, is then an excellent analog.  However, this interpretation is only one possibility.  Even if EARPHONES ON BI-FORK is indeed a ligature, the basic elements may be analyzed differently.  Another singleton, CUPPED DOWN BI-FORK, resembles this one, but inverted and without the circles (V35).  This sign, V35, occurs at Mohenjo daro just like the three variants of VII 41.  Finally, one of the ANKH variants may be a ROOF ON BI-FORK (V39), as Wells seems to suggest (W66) – also from Mohenjo daro.
Detail of seal M-101 with inscription: CIRCLED VEE / BI-QUOTES // EARPHONES ON BI-FORK (VII 41 A) /
POT // STRIPED TRIANGLE / TRI-FORK (note straight stem of BI-FORK, not curved, and not tilted to one side).

In proto-cuneiform, a symbol resembling the EARPHONES portion represents “child; young (of herd animals)” or low rank.  This sign, termed TUR, has an analog in proto-Elamite as well (M370~b), where it is more angular.  A variant of the latter has an additional element, a wedge-shaped impression between the “arms” of the “balance” (M370~k).  If one assumes that the people of the Indus Valley learned to write from their Near Eastern neighbors, then the symbol I call EARPHONES might be the local equivalent of proto-cuneiform TUR, meaning “offspring,” more or less.  The addition of an element such as the BI-FORK to the original symbol might then be another example of gunification – modification of the meaning of an original, standardized symbol by adding a non-standardized stroke (or strokes).  In proto-cuneiform (and proto-Elamite), gunification of the sign indicating a head of small cattle provides additional information on the specific type / gender / age of the livestock.  So, gunification of EARPHONES might indicate a the sex of the offspring (boy or girl for humans, ewe or ram for lambs, etc.).
From top down, proto-Elamite M370~k, pE M370~b, variants of proto-cuneiform TUR,
possible inspiration for Indus VII 41, indicating "child; young (of herd animals); low in rank."

There are other possibilities as well, though.  In Chinese, there is an element rather like a modern plus sign (+) with diagonal strokes below the central horizontal.  This is mu4, “tree; wood.”  In Old Chinese, the horizontal line was a “U” shape, the two lower diagonals a “roof” shape.  In the earlier Old Seal script, another character includes this early form, adding two small circles to the upper branches of the “U” and a small square to the top of the central vertical.  There is also a small, inverted “Y” shape on top of the small square.  Together, these elements form yao4, “a wooden support on which a drum and bells are hung....The orchestrion of old Yao, music in general.  When read lao4...the effect produced by music, pleasure, joy” (Wieger 1965: 224).  As far as the interpretation of the Indus sign is concerned, this suggests that combining basic elements can produce a symbol for an object or concept far removed from the original elements.  In Chinese, lao4 has nothing to do with trees, even though the character for “tree; wood” is still clearly there, but now means “pleasure, joy.”

One last parallel to the Indus EARPHONES ON BI-FORK comes from Luwian hieroglyphs.  The ideograph REL, “relative, kinsman,” has an upper portion resembling the Indus EARPHONES.  But the Luwian glyph has incomplete loops rather than circles.  In addition, the central stem of REL is merely a straight vertical line, in variant “a.”  In variant “b,” the stem of REL takes on a curve at the base, forming a “J.”  A third variant, “c,” has a squared off version of the “J” which more resembles a backward “L.”  In this script, the variations on the stem appear to convey no distinction in meaning.  It is quite possible that the variations in the Indus EARPHONES ON BI-FORK similarly carry no change in significance of the symbol, but are simply stylistic variants.
Indus seal H-413 with sign VII 42 over unicorn:
STACKED FIVE UNDER ROOF (seal is broken).

The second Indus symbol discussed here is STACKED FIVE UNDER ROOF (VII 42), also known as KP338 and W225.  It does not appear in Fairservis’ list.  Wells notes it as a singleton from Harappa (H-413).  What is worse, the single seal on which it appears is broken, so we cannot say anything about its position relative to other signs.

Nevertheless, it has an interesting parallel in the proto-cuneiform GI6, “night; shade.”  This symbol has the same basic “U” shape, though turned sideways compared to the Indus sign.  Inside there are many small strokes or dots, perhaps up to 14 rather than just five.  The dots or short strokes in the proto-cuneiform sign do not appear to be grouped, either, while the Indus sign shows a row of three short verticals stacked neatly over a row of two such strokes.  The STACKED FIVE appears independently among the apparent numerals of the Indus proto-writing system, so it is possible that this “number” (if that’s what it is) has significance.

In proto-Elamite, an angular parallel appears (M343~h + M354).  In this instance, the outside element or “roof” has an inverted “V” shape (cf. the Indus CHEVRON which may or may not be a variant of the more curved ROOF).  At the base of one “leg” of this inverted “V” is an impressed circle.  Another impressed circle appears beneath the angular “roof,” with seven short diagonal strokes around it.  The lower element, the impressed circle with dots around it, is a numerical measure found in two systems, the ŠE, both Š and Š#.  In the first of these, the circle-and-dots form the second lowest measure, two of which add up to one of the next higher measure (written with an impressed circle surrounded by six more circles).  In the second –probably related system from Tepe Yahya – the circle surrounded by dots is the lowest measure.  However, there are no other Indus signs made up of a ROOF over other numbers of short strokes.

Old Chinese writing makes use of a “roof” element as well, placing various other elements beneath this.  One such character is liang3, “two weights equal, state of balance” (Wieger 1965: 100).  Here there is a long, central vertical beneath the roof, with a small, inverted “Y” on either side.  Another character apparently derived from a roof over a more abstract symbol of five strokes is zong1, “an ancestral hall....The building from which emanates...the influence of the deceased ancestors over their posterity” (1965: 101).

Luwian hieroglyphs include a glyph something like a “U” turned sideways, inside which are three small circles.  This is MALUS, the ideograph for “bad.”  A variant resembles our number “3” (reversed), with two dots inside each “roof.”  This is an example of including number-like marks to form a non-numerical symbol.  Interestingly enough, the ideograph IUDEX / IUSTITIA, “ruler; justice,” appears to be a modified “roof” over two short strokes.  Again, an apparently numeral – two – helps to convey a completely non-numerical meaning.

In the rock art of North America, dots or short strokes sometimes appear inside “cups” or below “roofs.”  One western example contains no less than 42 dots: a row of 10 over another row of 10 over third and fourth rows, each containing 11 (Heizer and Baumhoff 1984: 356, fig. F-17l).  At the bottom of the symbol there are also nine prongs.  This combination of “cup,” contained marks in row, and prongs beneath, also appears in Texas (Newcomb and Kirkland 1996: 153, Pl. 105, no. 1).  In this instance there are four prongs asymmetrically arranged and 13 short, horizontal strokes inside (arranged 5 x 5 x 3).  These American motifs provide examples of an apparent combination of a CUP ON PRONGS and a container with contents, that is, a combination of Indus signs VII 42 and VII 43.
Bar seal M-354 with inscription: MAN HOLDING DEE-SLASH / BACK CEE & CEE / BI-QUOTES //
CAGED FISH UNDER CHEVRON / SLASHES IN OVERLAPPING CIRCLES / QUINT-FORK /
CUP ON THREE PRONGS UNDER CHEVRON (VII 44 A) / POT.

Sign VII 43 is a CUP ON FIVE PRONGS, found elsewhere only in Wells (W33).  It is a singleton, although possible variants with fewer prongs have been noted previously (see posts on V 37 and VI 57, CUPS on 3 and 4 PRONGS respectively).  This particular number of prongs (5) does not occur elsewhere, so far as I can tell, although “cups” on “prongs” are hardly rare.
Detail of seal M-89 with inscription: FISH UNDER CHEVRON / TWO POSTS /
CUP ON FIVE PRONGS / RAYED CIRCLE / POT.
In Old Chinese, a very low and flattened “U” on four prongs is part of the composite character meng2, meaning “to clear up an obscure affair, by swearing, in the old way, upon a vessel full of blood” (Wieger 1965: 119).  In this case, the “cup on prongs” portion represents the vessel containing blood, while the upper or contained element is an independent character meaning “bright” or “clear (up).”
Analogs to VII 43: motif from Texas (left) and proto-cuneiform UMBIN~b1 (right).

Proto-cuneiform makes use of few “cups on prongs,” but there is UMBIN~b1.  This is an outline “C” shape with numerous short prongs on the outer rim.  It came to mean “nail, claw, talon” in Sumerian although it does not much resemble any of these appendages in this early form.  Finally, a modified “cup” sits on four prongs in a Texan motif (Newcomb and Kirkland 1996: 154, Pl. 106, no. 2).

Detail from seal M-810 with inscription:
CUP ON THREE PRONGS UNDER CHEVRON (VII 44 B) / POT.
Our third Indus symbol is CUP ON THREE PRONGS UNDER CHEVRON (VII 44).  It is also noted by Koskenniemi and Parpola (KP314) and Wells (W315), but not Fairservis.  Wells finds two instances, both from Mohenjo daro, occurring in two variants.  The “a” variant has a longer, central “prong” which curves off to one side (M-354), while the “b” variant sits on three prongs that are equally short.

I noted the proto-cuneiform symbol U4, “sun, day,” in the blog entry that dealt with the Indus BOAT.  This “C” curve contains a reversed and smaller curve, said to represent the sun rising between hills (though it closely resembles representations of the lunar crescent of other cultures).  In proto-cuneiform, additional strokes are commonly added to enumerate days.  Sometimes the additional elements are wedges, as in |U4.3(N08)| for “three days,” and sometimes attached “prongs,” as in |U4.SZU2| for “two days.”  We might expect the number of prongs attached to the Indus CUP to be similarly enumerative.

However, in Old Chinese, a symbol resembling a modified “V” shaped cup sitting on three prongs has non-numerical meaning.  This character is man2, “before the equilibrium is perfect, the balance [is] oscillating hither and thither” (Wieger 1965: 100).  In this case – if Wieger’s interpretation is correct – the “prongs” represent a balance or scales, while the upper portion (the apparent “cup”) depicts oscillation.
Detail of seal M-120 with inscription: QUADRUPED (abraded) /
OVERLAPPING CIRCLES / POTTED ONE / EF PRONGED EXIT /
WINGED MAN / POT // HAMMER IN DIAMOND.

Indus sign VII 45 is similar but based on a different sign: POTTED ONE (KP325, W290 and W299, and Fs J-6).  Fairservis considers the basic “U” with “F” shaped sides to represent a pot (his J-5), here modified by the addition of affix P1 (my SINGLE QUOTE).  Although he considers the POT to be an honorific suffix, adding the genitive affix does not add up to an agglutinative super-suffix.  Instead, the ligature designates “up, upper, up river,” or even “north,” in Fairservis’ view.  It is probably significant that the apparent suffix, the simple POT, is the most common terminal in the analysis by Korvink, but the POTTED ONE is a medial element.  (And note that Parpola interprets the basic "pot" as cattle horns, not a container.)
Circular tablet from Chanhujo daro with inscription (right to left and top to bottom):
POTTED ONE / HAIRY HUNCHBACK (?) // POTTED ONE / FLAIL / FISH
(note the more or less "V" shaped POTS).
Wells usually groups “U” and “V” shaped elements together under a single heading, but here he separates them.  His W290 is the “U” shape, with 75 occurrences.  Of these, 52 are from Mohenjo daro, 12 from Harappa, three from Lothal, four from Kalibangan, three from Chanhujo daro, and one from Rangpur.  The V shape (W299) is a singleton from Nindowari-damb (Nwd-3).  I prefer to group these together, designating the first VII 45 A and the second VII 45 B.  In any case, the distinction between the "U" and "V" shapes is not all that clearcut, as the example from Chanhujo-daro demonstrates.

In proto-cuneiform, again noting the “day” symbol as a parallel form, an additional mark is typically numerical.  The addition of a line inside the “C” curve indicates “one day,” transcribed |U4 x 1(N57)|, as does the addition of a circular impression inside, transcribed |U4 x 1(N14)|.  If the Indus POTTED ONE includes a numerical element in such a fashion, we would expect this sign to represent one of whatever the basic POT designates.  However, it is a notable fact that POTTED ONE (and POTTED TWO, POTTED THREE, etc.) occurs in the inscriptions in a position unlike that of the basic POT, as previously observed.  This essential fact strongly suggests that, once again, additional strokes in the Indus system are not numerals.
Bloc of Luwian hieroglyphs.
Among the Luwian glyphs, an element resembling a pot typically contains two short strokes.  This symbol is a phonetic glyph representing the syllable pa.  Clearly, then, the inclusion of apparent numerals need not convey numerical information.

There is a west African Adinkra symbol that somewhat resembles the Indus CUP with a floral-like element inside.  This is called osram ne nsoroma.  It represents the moon and a star but symbolizes such qualities as faithfulness, harmony, love, loyalty, and femininity (Willis 1998: 178).
Harappan tablet H-228 with inscription (right to left):
COMB / POT-HATTED BEARER / DOUBLE BACK CEES / CUPPED SPOON ON FIVE PRONGS (W310a).

Finally, Indus sign VII 46 combines both an insert and added prongs: CUPPED POST ON FOUR PRONGS.  Wells alone includes this in his list, as W319.  He observes three occurrences, one from Mohenjo daro and two from Harappa.  Only the first of these is made up of seven strokes, being a “U” shape on four prongs with a single vertical inside (Wells’ “b” variant).  Grouped with this “variant” in Wells’ analysis is a “U” shape on five prongs, with the SPOON inside – his “a” variant, comprised of ten strokes.
Sign VII 46 from broken seal M-1049 (W310b).

Proto-cuneiform provides a parallel in another variation on the “day” sign: |U4 x 1(N01).5(N08)|.  Here, there is a single wedge inside U4, which appears to indicate “one day,” with an additional stack of eight wedges alongside (= “eight days”?).  Cretan hieroglyphs also include a “cup” shape on prongs with an insert.  This symbol sits on three prongs and contains a more elaborate internal element.  The glyph is enumerated O55 (according to Younger’s website) and may represent the syllable ke (it might also be an early Cretan ideograph that only later evolved into a phonetic symbol in Linear A and/or Linear B).
A tilted “U” shape appears in Texas, resting on three prongs and with its “post” above and to the right (Newcomb and Kirkland 1996: 101, Pl. 58).  This combination of elements may or may not comprise a single motif.

Saturday, May 7, 2011

More Indus Rarities: Mallet, Top, Pants, and Doorway

The thirty-seventh sign in my list of symbols containing seven strokes (VII 37) is a striped rectangle with a short vertical on top, a symbol I term DOUBLY STRIPED MALLET.  With just two horizontal stripes, hence exactly seven strokes, it occurs only as W470 elsewhere (similar signs, KP280 and Fs N-10, each have three internal stripes).  Wells notes four variations, this seven-stroke variant (containing two stripes), an eight-stroke variant (with three stripes), a nine-stroke variant (with four stripes), and a ten-stroke variant (with five stripes).  Without identifying which type occurs where or how often, Wells indicates a total of 23 STRIPED MALLETS, 12 from Mohenjo daro, nine from Harappa, one from Lothal, and one from Kalibangan.  He also classifies as a singleton an occurrence of two eight-stroke variants side by side (W472, from Harappa).

Detail from seal M-809 with inscription (over unicorn horn):
BACK CEE & CEE / DOUBLY STRIPED MALLET / BI-QUOTES //
STRIPED TRIANGLE / TRIPLE TRIANGLES / SPEAR.

I have not discovered an exact duplicate of the STRIPED MALLET in another set of symbols, but there are several instances of a square or rectangle with one or more internal marks, as well as an attached or protruding stroke.  In Egyptian, one hieroglyph represents a standing man pounding in a mortar (A34).  Although it is not striped, the mortar has the shape of a square, the long pestle resembling the vertical of the Indus MALLET.  The glyph is a determinative in a word meaning, “to pound, to build.”  Thus, the Indus sign might depict a mortar and pestle just as in Egyptian.

In proto-cuneiform, MAR is a rectangle with a single internal stripe and an attached post.  As is typical, the sign extends horizontally rather than vertically.  In one variant, the internal stripe is nearer the end of the rectangle where the “post” attaches, while another variant has its stripe closer to the opposite end of the rectangle (both designated MAR~a).  A third variant adds a number of stripes between the original stripe and the end of the containing rectangle (MAR~a@t).  These seem to be the symbol that came to mean “wagon, cart; winnowing shovel, spoon; to sow; western.”  If this is correct, the sign may originally have depicted a bird’s-eye view of a wagon with its attached yoke – minus the wheels.  This provides a second possible interpretation of the Indus symbol.  There is another MAR in Sumerian, however.  It means "earthworm."  If the proto-cuneiform sign also represented an earthworm, it becomes rather difficult to see the symbol as pictorial.
Proto-cuneiform "mallets" -- MAR~a (top left),
MAR~a @ t (top right), USZ~b (at bottom).
Another proto-cuneiform “mallet,” this one with the “post” attached on the opposite side, is USZ, “foundation.”  This recalls the Egyptian meaning for the glyph of the man using a mortar and pestle, “to build.”  There are, in addition, two proto-Elamite symbols that are shaped similarly, though their meanings are unknown.  The first of these contains cross-hatching rather than one or more stripes (M155~f).  The other has two short stripes, but rather than crossing the “head” of the “mallet” they extend from the right end only halfway into the “head” (M159).  Also, there are two short “posts” on the left side rather than one.

Simple though the “mallet” shape appears to be, it does not appear among the rectilinear designs found in the rock art of the American Southwest.  The closest facsimile is a motif from Texas comprising a tall rectangle with a single vertical stripe and four horizontal ones (Newcomb and Kirkland 1996: 188, Pl. 138, no. 17-A).  Rather than a post on top, this design has an inverted triangle that is, itself, striped.  The motif may be an incomplete anthropomorph (i.e., the head and body of a human or deity).  Other anthropomorphic motifs have this same general shape, with arms and/or legs attached.  However, this particular arrangement of internal decor appears to be rare.
Detail from seal M-31 with inscription: CARTWHEEL / PINCH //
BELTED FISH / DOUBLY STRIPED SKEWERED TOP / BIRD BETWEEN PARENS / POT.
The next Indus sign, the DOUBLY STRIPED SKEWERED TOP, is similar to the previous one in some respects (VII 38).  It is another rectangle adorned with two horizontal stripes.  In this case, the “post” extends through the rectangle, protruding both at the top and the bottom.  As a seven-stroke sign it appears elsewhere only as W485, where Wells notes five occurrences, two from Mohenjo daro and three from Harappa.

Wells also notes a nine-stroke TOP (W487, with four stripes) and a ten-stroke type (W489, with five stripes).  I prefer to designate the “variants” of both the TOP and the MALLET in the same way, with independent numerical identifications based on stroke number.  If other researchers prefer to group them together based on similarity of form, the “variants” could just as easily be indicated with letters, as is done for proto-cuneiform and proto-Elamite.  Apparently, Koskenniemi and Parpola lump them all together, listing only an eight-stroke version (KP275).  No striped “top” appears in Fairservis.

In Old Chinese, a circle crossed by a long, protruding horizontal line and containing a vertical stripe formed the character guan4, “to pierce, to string, to tie together different objects” (Wieger 1965: 319).  This character is now a skewered square, as all elements that were originally round have become angular.
Proto-cuneiform AK~a (upper left), AK~b (on right), and BANSZUR~b2 (center).

Proto-cuneiform includes two distinct signs of a generally similar shape.  One is a square with internal markings -- six short diagonal strokes, grouped in two stacks of three.  There is a post attached on the right and another on the left, duplicating the basic form of the Indus "top" (AK~a).  A variant (AK~b) has the same form but is rotated 90 degrees so that it more resembles the Indus sign.  Inside this variant, there are six chevrons rather than diagonal strokes.  AK eventually means “to do,” though what it originally represented is less clear.  The other sign is BANSZUR~b2, “table.”  In this case, the angular portion of the "top" is a wide rectangle rather than a square.  There are two internal stripes, as in the Indus sign.  But the “post” does not cross the whole symbol.  Instead, there is a post on the right and another on the left, as with AK, although here these attachments touch the internal stripe.
Bar seal M-1316 with inscription: BISECTED SQUARE / CEE & SLASHa / TWO POSTS /
MALLET / PANTS / DOUBLE DOWN HEARTS / MAN HOLDING DOUBLE DEE-SLASHES.

The following Indus sign is rather peculiar (VII39).  It resembles three nested chevrons (or rather, "less than" signs: <<< ) with an additional stroke joining the ends on one side.  This motif vaguely recalls a cartoon drawing of trousers, so I have given it – and its many variants – the provisional name PANTS.  This particular variation on this odd theme occurs elsewhere only as W167 (but see VIII 19, in a later post, for a discussion of all the variants, including KP205).  It is a singleton, Wells states, from Mohenjo daro (M-1316).

It is reasonably close to a proto-Elamite sign (M059~d).  This sign is rotated 90 degrees compared to the Indus symbol, again a typical feature.  Unfortunately, its meaning is unknown so I am unable to propose a better designation than PANTS.  Nor do other scripts or symbols provide assistance in this area.  There are various motifs in North American rock art that contain parallel zigzags and one might consider the "chevrons" (or "less than" signs) to be very short zigzags.  In one instance in Texas there are precisely three parallel zigzags joined by a baseline (Newcomb and Kirkland 1996: 176, Pl. 124, no. 1-C).  But this is fairly remote from the original Indus design.
Detail from broken bar seal M-1367 with inscription (and back end of one bison):
DOORWAY / VEE IN DIAMOND  (note base on the former, as shown in Wells).

The last symbol discussed in this post is the DOORWAY (VII 40), also known as KP272, W491, and Fs G-5.  It is Fairservis who designates the sign as a gate or doorway to a house.  This may or may not be correct, but it as good a designation as any.  Wells notes only three occurrences, two from Mohenjo daro and one from Kalibangan.  He also states that there is but a single variant.  However, interestingly enough, the sign is shown differently in the three lists cited.  Fairservis makes it an incomplete rectangle, rather like the TABLE, although outlined (“fat” in my terms).  This might be a variant "A" (as the symbol appears in K-89).  Koskenniemi and Parpola show a truncated cone containing a rectangle. This might be a variant "B" (although seal M-21 shows only a slightly tapering toward the top of the outer "rectangle").  Wells has a rectangle in a larger rectangle, perhaps a variant "C" (as shown in M-1367).
Detail from impression K-89 with barely legible inscription:
CIRCLED DOT (?) / SQUARE AY / BI-QUOTES // DOORWAY / POT / MAN (?)
(note the apparent lack of a baseline on the DOORWAY, as shown in Fairservis).
It may be that Fairservis was influenced by similar Egyptian glyphs, including one which acts as a determinative for “door, gateway” (O32).  The glyph is somewhat more complex than the Indus sign, but it provides some support for this interpretation.  However, another roughly rectangular glyph is an equally good parallel, representing the facade of a shrine (O21).  It is an ideograph or determinative in sh-ntr, “the divine booth.”  There is even a third glyph containing a truncated cone shape – among other details – that is a heap of grain, the ideograph or determinative in šnwt, “granary.”  Thus, the Indus symbol could represent a pile of grain or a building of some sort, just as easily as a doorway.
Egyptian glyphs O21 (left) and O32 (right). 
The first is a shrine; the second a doorway or gateway.

In Old Chinese, there is an element that is sometimes curved and sometimes more angular, with an open base like the version of VII 40 depicted in Fairservis’ list.  With two stacked circles tucked beneath, this is gung1, “a big building; several rooms under the same roof...used to designate the Imperial private resident” (Wieger 1965: 228).  In a number of inscriptions on bronze cult vessels, the overarching symbol appears to represent a shrine (1971: 364).  In the inscription seen on the right, though, the shrine appears at the top, with symbols representing the ancestor inside.  Beneath this is the roof element with additional strokes beneath it, together forming a character.  Below this are two additional characters side by side (representing offerings of meat and libations, according to Wieger).  Below these two, the roof appears again, this time with a simple "+" inside -- another composite character.  This might be zhu4, which now means "space behind the throne," while a related character, pronounced the same way, means "to await, expect."  While I cannot interpret the inscription precisely, the "roof" element is fairly clear.  It provides one possible interpretation of the Indus DOORWAY.

Proto-cuneiform includes a symbol that is somewhat more elaborate, but a possible analog.  In form, it is a long rectangle with one crossing vertical stripe near the left end, two horizontals running from this first stripe to the right end, and three short verticals joining the two horizontals (UR3~b1).  This odd symbol came to have quite a variety of seemingly unrelated meanings: “roof; entrance; mountain pass; rafter, beam; cross bar, bolt; yoke, harness; to drag, erase, mow, reap.”  If “entrance” proves to be the original meaning, it may provide additional support for Fairservis’ interpretation of the Indus symbol, VII 40.  Finally, proto-Elamite has a rectangle inside a rectangle, for what that is worth (M146~d).  However, the smaller rectangle is centered in this symbol, while the small rectangle in the Indus sign shares the same base as the larger rectangle.
Proto-Elamite M146~d (above) and proto-cuneiform UR3~b1 (below).
The latter came to have many meanings, including "roof" and "entrance."

If the rather equivocal evidence from Egyptian, Old Chinese, and proto-cuneiform suggests an interpretation of the Indus sign as a building (or an entrance to one), we might expect to find a similar representation in other areas.  I expected to find such an element in the rock art of the American Southwest, for example, since some Native Americans built dwellings with angular shapes.  Specifically, squares and rectangles of some sort might be expected to appear in the art of modern pueblo dwellers, such as the Hopi, Zuni, and others – or in the artwork of their ancestors.  However, in the collections of art to which I have access, I have not seen much to suggest this.  There are triangular motifs which may represent teepees, or similar structures, in Texas (e.g., Newcomb and Kirkland 1996: 207, Pl. 152, no. 5).  More rarely, there are stepped motifs which recall the pyramids of Central America (e.g., 1996: 176, Pl. 124, no. 1-C).
Tablet M-1427B (inscription is on the A side), showing a stepped motif.
Two such stepped motifs appear on a tablet in bas-relief from Mohenjo-daro (M-1427B).  While this does not appear to be a sign of the same type as those found in inscriptions, it might be a representation of some type of structure (though nothing like a stepped pyramid or ziggurat has been excavated in the Indus Valley).  It is reminiscent of the Indus DOORWAY sign (VII 40) and perhaps this sign is a simplified rendering of the same thing.  A "stepped pyramid" does appear among the proto-cuneiform signs (see the discussion of the STRIPED TRIANGLE for an illustration).  This motif also appears at Altyn Depe in Central Asia (Masson 1988: Pl. XVIII).  Since an Indus type seal was discovered at Altyn Depe -- and a seal bearing a type of bird known from Altyn Depe was found in the Indus Valley -- there was clearly some cultural contact between these two areas.  It is possible, too, that there is some relationship between one or more Indus signs and motifs found at Altyn Depe, including the DOORWAY sign.
Crosses and stepped motifs as shown on a box from Altyn Depe.


Monday, April 11, 2011

Five Rare Indus Signs

This post includes brief discussions of five Indus signs, each drawn with seven strokes.  None appears frequently and none has very many parallels in the scripts or artwork of other places.  The first is shaped like a single parenthesis with a small triangle attached, a feature I have previously termed an “ear.”  There are also four short strokes descending at a shallow angle from the inner curve.  The clumsy appellation for this sign, thus far, is QUADRUPLE LASHES ON CEE WITH EAR (VII 32).  It appears elsewhere only in the list prepared by Koskenniemi and Parpola, where it is KP159.  I have yet to see this symbol, but I present an illustration below, based on its form in the published list.

QUADRUPLE LASHES ON BACK CEE WITH EAR, as it might appear beside TOP
(not actually observed by author).
In Luwian hieroglyphs, there is a symbol vaguely resembling this one, a curving line with three diagonal lines attached.  However, in this case the diagonal strokes attach to the outer portion of the curve, rather than the inside.  Proto-cuneiform also contains a curving symbol, with strokes attached on the inside this time, but six of these added bits.  One variant has an “ear” as well, but this characteristic is on the inside of the curve, along with the “lashes.”  This is IB, which came to mean “corner, angle.”

The Indus sign also bears a faint resemblance to a motif found in the rock art of the Southwest.  The American design resembles a comb, but one end of the back curves around and back over the symbol (Heizer and Baumhoff 1984: 140, fig. 77b; p. 148, fig. 85d).  The motif may symbolize rain, though at least some of these “rain” motifs may be schematic quadrupeds (most likely mountain sheep).  I add an illustration of several quadrupeds found in the art of Texas below (Newcomb and Kirkland 1996: 206, Pl. 150, no. 3; p. 207, Pl. 152, no. 7).
Various possible quadrupeds as they appear in American rock art:
gray forms appear in a single panel, but the darker shapes are added by author,
simply for easy comparison.

The next Indus symbol is what I call STRIPED FOOTED STOOL (VII 33).  Also known as W463, it does not appear in the list of signs by Fairservis or that of Koskenniemi and Parpola.  Wells notes the sign as a singleton, appearing only at Mohenjo daro (M-119).
Seal M-119 with inscription (reversed, reading from right to left):
STRIPED FOOTED STOOL /  CEE / TWO POSTS / BLANKET (6 TICKS) /
MAN HOLDING DEE-SLASH / TRI-FORK / BI-QUOTES //
STRIPED FAT CHEVRON / STRIPED VEST / CHEVRON-HATTED (?) BEARER.

Luwian hieroglyphs contain an ideograph that depicts an actual stool or seat, THRONUS, “throne.”  This symbol bears some resemblance to the Indus sign, but lacks the inner striping.  In addition, the legs of this actual seat are typically curved, while the comparable elements of the Indus sign are straight.

In proto-cuneiform, there is a sign identified as ZAG, more of a “bowtie” than a “stool.”  One variant contains one stripe in each half while another variant contains two stripes in each part.  The symbol came to mean “boundary, border,” among other things.  Proto-Elamite has a symbol more closely resembling an Indus “stool” in M105.  The “stool” is lying on its side -- as is the Indus sign -- and has a concave “seat.”  There are also two stripes below the “seat.”  This “stool” has no feet, though, unlike the Indus sign.

Further afield, there is a “bowtie” among the Adinkra symbols of west Africa.  This is a depiction of a “talking drum,” called dono ntoaso (Willis 1998: 92).  It symbolizes united action, alertness, good will, and praise.  Also clearly representational is the “bowtie” shape found in Texas in rock art (Newcomb and Kirkland 1996: 141, Pl. 97, no. 1).  In this case, this is the form taken by the torso of a human or deity, as demonstrated by the common addition of feet, arms, and/or head (though sometimes one or another of these elements is missing).

Our third symbol is STRIPE BELTED AITCH WITH TICK, a term awkward in the extreme.  I enumerate this sign VII 34 as the thirty-fourth of the seven-stroke symbols.  It appears only as KP298(a) in published lists.  It resembles the letter “H” but with two horizontal lines crossing it rather than just one.  In addition, there are two short verticals joining these two “belt” lines, reminiscent of a belt buckle (hence my dreadful name for the sign).  Appended to the base of the sign, on one side, is a slightly curved horizontal stroke.  I have not seen this in the Concordance, but I have created an illustration as it might appear, below.
Illustration of STRIPE BELTED AITCH WITH TICK as it might
appear on a seal, over head of "unicorn."

Having not observed the Indus sign, I wondered at first whether Koskenniemi and Parpola could have mistaken a stray mark on some tablet or seal for the “tick.”  If this were the case, then there would be no VII 34 as identified and this would merely be an instance of the STRIPE BELTED AITCH.  But there is a sign in proto-cuneiform that bears some similarity to this Indus one.  The proto-cuneiform is ZATU 754, an obscure symbol made up of three vertical posts joined by a single horizontal, with a single diagonal attached at upper right.  While the basic form of the sign is rather different from that of the Indus symbol, the attached diagonal recalls the Indus “tick.”  In proto-Elamite, in contrast, one sign resembles the “double-belted aitch” portion, though with an “X” between the lines of the “belt” rather than two little verticals (M026).  It lacks an equivalent to the "tick."

Detail of seal M-724 with inscription: VEE IN DIAMOND / BI-QUOTES // CIRCLE / PAW / TRI-FORK
(it is not clear to me whether the CIRCLE should be "read" as following BI-QUOTES --
as I transcribed it here -- or as a 2nd row, i.e., following the TRI-FORK).


The next Indus sign under consideration is PAW (VII 35).  Elsewhere, it is KP322 and W309, but Fairservis does not mention it.  Wells notes four occurrences, all from Mohenjo daro.  I am by no means implying that the Harappans were trying to draw an animal’s foot with this symbol, but it resembles schematic paw prints as shown in some of my books on American Indian art (especially when I haven’t read them recently and can’t quite remember what the originals look like).
Analogs of the Indus STRIPED STOOL (from left): proto-Elamite M105,
proto-cuneiform ZAG~b, and Adinkra dono ntoaso.

The proto-cuneiform SZU, meaning “hand; a share” has a similar off-balance shape to it.  So does TAK4~a, which came to mean “remainder; to leave, abandon.”  The closest analogies in proto-Elamite and American rock art, however, are bilaterally symmetrical (M129~b, which is triangular; Newcomb and Kirkland 1996: 193, Pl. 143, no. 23-F).

The final Indus sign for this post is TRIPLE CLAWED PAW UNDER TABLE (VII 36), also known as KP321 and W337.  It is not found in Fairservis.  Wells gives it as another singleton, this time from Lothal (L-93).  It has the same unbalanced look of the previous sign, but lacks one “toe” and the horizontal across the top of the “claws.”
Broken bar seal L-93 with inscription: CARTWHEEL / STRIPED MALLET /
SINGLE QUOTE / TRIPED CLAWED PAW UNDER TABLE.
There is a slight resemblance to the proto-Elamite sign resembling a schematic hand (M505).  There is also a faint similarity (minus the TABLE) to an Old Chinese character, chen2, “minister, attendant on a prince” (Wieger 1965: 214).  The latter supposedly represents the minister seen head on, as he is bowing his head to the floor before the king.  However, if that is the case, one wonders why the character can appear horizontally or vertically, or even tilted like a crescent moon.
Versions of Old Chinese chen2, "minister, attendant on a prince" (based on Wieger 1965: 214).
The central variant supposedly represents this official lying prostrate before the prince, as seen
head on.  This one slightly resembles Indus sign VII36, though without the TABLE.