Friday, July 29, 2011

Beasts in the Indus Script: Quadruped, Crustacean, and Fish Variations



Bar seal Krs-1 with inscription: CUPPED SPOON / QUADRUPED (X31) /
SHISH KEBAB / PINCH // THREE POSTS / CIRCLED TRIPLE BRICK /
PANTS / CHEVRON / SINGLE QUOTE // STACKED TRIPLE CIRCLES.
In the sign list of Koskenniemi and Parpola, there is a schematic quadruped of ten strokes (KP44) that also appears in Wells’ list (W174).  I term this particular symbol QUADRUPED WITH ROUND FACE AND STRAIGHT TAIL (X31) as I cannot identify the animal.  Wells notes five occurrences, three of them from Mohenjo daro and one apiece from Lothal and Khirsara.  There is actually some variation among these instances listed by Wells.  Sometimes there seem to be ears, sometimes not, and the “face” is more angular in certain variations.  It is difficult to determine which features are significant, since the animal is unidentified.
Two quadrupeds, one a camel, from Tassili n'Ajjer in North Africa,
alongside Tifinagh script (LeQuellec 2004: 43, fig. 42)

As noted with previous zoomorphic signs, other scripts include quadrupeds quite frequently.  There are quite a few in Old Chinese, many among the Egyptian hieroglyphs, and even one unidentified example in proto-cuneiform (although heads alone appear to have been preferred).  The rock art of most continents also contains schematic representations of quadrupeds of one kind or another.  In his review of African rock art, Le Quellec distinguishes the zoomorph in side view from that shown from above, the latter described as the “bedside rug” type.  The Indus script seems to include only side views, no flattened “bedside rugs.”
Detail from seal M-66 with inscription: CORN HOLDER / LONG-LEGGED CRAB / BUD
BI-QUOTES // FISH UNDER CHEVRON / MALLET / TRI-FORK / POT (note the crowding
of the signs that causes a nonlinear arrangement on the right).

In the discussion of six-stroke Indus signs, I mentioned the CRAB, a pointed oval with attached “pincers.”  An apparent variation on this simple form is the LONG-LEGGED CRAB (X 32).  It appears elsewhere as KP206 and W171.  Wells notes it as a singleton from Mohenjo daro (M-66).  It actually more resembles a modified STOOL, since the back end of the zoomorph is pretty flat.  This may indicate that the STOOL is also a simplified zoomorph.
Possible crustaceans and insects in proto-cuneiform:
ZATU 703 (upper left), KUSZU2~e (upper right),
and ZATU 699~a and ~b (bottom row).

There are relatively few insects and crustaceans in Egyptian hieroglyphs aside from the bee and scarab or dung beetle.  Three or four appear in proto-cuneiform, including what may be a lobster (ZATU 703), something like a ladybug (ZATU699~a and ~b), and some sort of aquatic animal.  The latter is KUSZU2~e, later symbolizing a crab, most likely, although a turtle or shark is possible.  However, the Indus sign does not particularly resemble any of these.
Broken seal L-47 with partial inscription: STACKED NINE (?) / CRAB / BI-QUOTES //
DUCK HEAD / PINWHEEL (over incomplete "unicorn" at the bottom).

There follows DUCK HEAD (EYELESS) (X 33), also known as KP76 and W86.  Fairservis only includes a variation with a dot in the center of the circle, hence his identification of it as the head of a bird with its beak wide open to make noise (B-6).  It is more likely another form of insect or crustacean, I think.  Wells notes four variants.  These differ in the number of “legs” and the shape of the “pincers” – if it is a crab (varying in the number of “feathers” and the shape of the “beak” if it really is a bird’s head).  Wells finds nine occurrences, with all four types appearing at Mohenjo daro.  There is also an instance of the “a” variant from Lothal (L-47).
Two variants of proto-cuneiform NE, "this, that."

A similar symbol appears in proto-cuneiform in the form of a circle to which several prongs are attached on the left and a “less than” sign on the right.  The sign occurs in two variants, NE~a showing a vertical line across the circle; NE~b including a “greater than” element instead.  The sign came to mean “this; that,” giving us no clue to what it may depict (if anything).
Broken and abraded seal M-39 (detail) with inscription:
QUADRUPED / EYES WITH QUADRUPLE LASHES (?) / STACKED THREE (?) /
FISH UNDER CHEVRON / WHISKERED FISH / CUPPED POST (?) / TRI-FORK (??).

The figure eight – a circle on top of another circle – occurs in the Indus script in various incarnations.  A ten-stroke variation is EYES WITH TRIPLE LASHES (X34).  In this, there are three diagonal strokes attached to each circle.  If rotated 90 degrees, the symbol would resemble Orphan Annie’s eyes with three eyelashes on each side.  Fairservis notes a version with four “lashes” (C-2), suggesting it may represent an insect, perhaps an ant (1992: 158).  The four-pronged version also shows up in the list of Koskenniemi and Parpola (KP83).  Only Wells includes this three-pronged version, as W87”a.”  The four-pronged type is his “b” variant.  He finds five occurrences altogether, three from Mohenjo daro and two from Harappa.  Both variants occur at both sites.  Although a "figure eight" appears on cultural artifacts elsewhere, one adorned with "lashes" does not seem to.
Bas-relief tablet H-206 with inscription (right to left): TRIPLE BRICK /
CUPPED POST / EYES WITH TRIPLE LASHES / WHISKERED FISH /
BLANKET WITH FOUR TICKS, TWO HYPHENS / POT.

The next sign in my list is CAGED WHISKERED FISH (X 35), also seen as KP63 and W120.  According to Wells, it occurs eight times, mostly at Mohenjo daro.  There is also a CAGED FISH UNDER CHEVRON (X 36), listed elsewhere as KP61 and W119.  This is slightly more common, with 11 occurrences, eight from Mohenjo daro, one from Harappa, one from Lothal, and one from Banawali.

Seal M-1091 with inscription: CUP ON FOUR PRONGS / RAYED CIRCLE /
CUPPED SPOON / MALLET / POT-HATTED BEARER / CAGED WHISKERED FISH.

Seal B-17 with inscription: MAN ON BASE / PANTS / BI-QUOTES //
CAGED FISH UNDER CHEVRON (over composite animal, part tiger, part bovine).

We then come to POTTED FOUR (X 37), like the previous symbols a variation on a theme seen previously.  It has been published as KP328, but does not appear in the other lists.  I find one instance, from Harappa (H-1005), on a pot shard.
Proto-cuneiform |ZATU 831 @ g|, similar to Indus X 37 (POTTED FOUR).

This is a very rare sign in the Indus Valley, but it has a parallel in proto-cuneiform.  A symbol reminiscent of the “pot,” rotated 90 degrees, occurs with six rather than four internal hash marks, as |ZATU 831 @ g|.  Unfortunately the meaning is unknown.  But the addition of apparent numerals to both signs, proto-cuneiform and Indus, may be significant (though not necessarily numerical).
Seal H-47 with inscription: FAT CHEVRON / STRIPED FLANGE-TOPPED POT (X38b) / POT
(note that both "flanges" stand out on the left; in the "a" variant, they stand on in the inside of the "pot").
Another variation on a previous theme is STRIPED FLANGE TOPPED POT (X 38), also known as KP332(d), W306, and Fs J-7.  Fairservis thinks it may represent a quantity of metal, as most examples occur on copper tablets.  He suggests that these tablets functioned as tokens for storage records (1992: 173).

Proto-cuneiform ZATU 710, two variants of a striped pot.

Proto-cuneiform has nothing like a “pot” with “flanges” on top, but there is a depiction of a striped pot: ZATU 710.  It has two variants, “a” having two strokes added as something like “handles,” and “b” including both these “handles” and another stroke for a possible “spout.”  Meanings are unknown.
Seal K-18 with inscription: LOOP ARMED MAN HOLDING BACKSLASH / TRIPLE TRIANGLE / BI-QUOTES //
FAT CHEVRON IN TRI-FORK TOPPED POT (?) / PANTS (sequence is unclear, due to nonlinear arrangement;
identification of the element inside the TRI-FORK TOPPED POT is also uncertain and may be a CARTWHEEL).

Indus signs X 39 and X 40 may be two different interpretations of a single sign.  The first of these is FAT CHEVRON IN TRI-FORK TOPPED POT, also known as KP334 and W324.  It is a singleton from Kalibangan (K18).  The second is CARTWHEEL IN TRI-FORK TOPPED POT, also known as KP337.
Proto-cuneiform |SZITA~a1 x UDU~a|, a vessel containing a sheep??

These two bear only the faintest resemblance to a proto-cuneiform sign, |SZITA~a1 x UDU~a|.  It takes the form of a triangular “vessel” with a wedge at the apex.  Inside the triangle is the circled cross.  In this combination, the internal element represents a sheep, while the “container” came to mean “priest; prayer; a sacred vessel.”  But it hardly seems likely that the meaning of the ligature is “cup of sheep.”
Bas-relief tablet H-228A with inscription (right to left): CUPPED SPOON ON 5 PRONGS /
DOUBLE BACK CEES / POT-HATTED LOOP ARMED MAN (BEARER?) / COMB.

One last simple variation is X 41 which I term CUPPED SPOON ON FIVE PRONGS.  It is also enumerated KP317(b) (actually the four-pronged variation) and W310”a.”  Wells has two variations grouped together, the “spoon” in a “cup” that sits on five prongs as “a”; the simpler “post” in a “cup” that sits on four prongs as “b.”  The simpler variant only occurs once at Mohenjo daro, while the ten-stroke version with the "spoon" appears twice at Harappa.
Proto-cuneiform U4, "day," with five prongs added, "five" (N57), indicating "five days."

In proto-cuneiform, I find nothing comparable to the Indus CUPPED SPOON, but the very broadly similar U4, “day,” sometimes takes prongs.  The instance with five prongs apparently represents “five days” (|U4 x 5(N57)|.  One might assume that if the addition of "prongs" has an enumerative function in proto-cuneiform, those added to the Indus sign would also have that function.  But this is not very likely, in reality.  In proto-cuneiform, U4 occurs with varying numbers of prongs, while the Indus CUPPED SPOON does not appear sitting on a wide variety of "numerals."

Wednesday, July 27, 2011

Anthropomorphic Ten-Stroke Signs in the Indus Script

Triangular tablet H-239 with inscription (right to left): DOUBLE MEN /
 BISECTED TRIANGLE / POT // SINGLE QUOTE (?) / TRI-FORK.


There are eight different signs based on the MAN sign in the Indus script, each of which contains ten strokes.  One consists of a doubling of the basic element, DOUBLE MEN (X 23), found in the literature as KP16 and W10.  Wells notes that there are 11 occurrences, three of them from Mohenjo daro, one from Harappa, and as many as seven from Kalibangan (though I think there are five from the first of these cities). 
Egyptian word rhyt, "people" with two phonetic symbols on the left, r and t,
and determinatives on the right -- seated man and seated woman -- over plural sign.

Egyptian hieroglyphic writing of the Bronze Age includes both phonetic symbols and determinatives.  The latter are signs that indicate something about the meaning of the given word and (presumably) were not pronounced.  Usually, the determinative is a single sign, but on occasion an additional symbol is added.  One example is the use of both the seated man (A1) and the seated woman (B1) together in words such as rhyt, “people,” and mrt, “peasants.”  Another example is the combination of a seated man with a pot on his head (A9) and the standing man holding a stick with both hands (A24), as in f3i, “to lift.”  Although the human figures in these instances bear little or no resemblance to the stick figure of the Indus inscriptions, the use of two signs to form a determinative may provide a parallel for the doubling of the Indus MAN.
Detail of Chinese basin with internal painted anthropomorphs, Majiayao culture (Yang 1999: 69). 

Elsewhere, the repetition of anthropomorphic figures appears outside the realm of writing proper, on pottery or as painted or carved on stone.  For example, a painted pottery basin of the Majiayao culture of the Chinese Neolithic shows a whole row of schematic anthropomorphs on the inside, holding hands (Yang 1999: 69).  Repeated figures with bent legs may depict a dance in Hohokam rock art (Noble 1991: 64).
Seal M-991 with inscription: MAN HOLDING SHISH KEBAB / SINGLE POST / POT-HATTED BEARER.

A more common type of anthropomorph in the Indus script appears to depict a person holding some object.  The second sign in this post is such a symbol, MAN HOLDING SHISH KEBAB (X 24), also known as KP28, W46, and Fs A-24.  (A version with three rather than four “kebabs” appears in an earlier post, as IX 28.)  As Wells notes, this sign is a singleton from Mohenjo daro (M-991).  Fairservis suggests that it represents a man with a stick for recording numerical amounts, defined as “record keeper (one who records by length, depth, amount).”  He provides additional remarks:

The notched or marked stick is one of the most universal signs in the ancient world.  Since man first kept records of any kind it appears that notching a piece of wood, bone or other material in sequence was the method used.  The symbol for this tool consists of variations on the vertical with cross-lines and is found, for example, in proto-Elamite, Archaic Sumerian and among the Vinca Cultures of Southweastern Europe (Fairservis 1992: 40).

Such marked sticks were a useful method of record-keeping even in historical times (Menninger 1969: 228, fig. 52).  In his account of words and symbols for numbers, Menninger provides many examples, including tally sticks from Switzerland which herders used to keep track of the amount of milk produced by local cows.  As evidence for Fairservis’ hypothesis, he cites an object found at Mohenjo daro, not a stick but a shell on which incised marks had been cut at right angles to the main axis of the object (1992: 40).
Seal H-94 with inscription: MAN HOLDING DONUT.

There is a similar human-like figure holding the circle within a circle: MAN HOLDING DONUT (X 25).  It appears in the literature as KP39 and W32.  Only slightly more common than the previous sign, it occurs once at Mohenjo daro and once at Harappa, as Wells observes.
Detail from seal M-99 with inscription: MAN HOLDING DIAMOND /
STRIPED FAT LEG LAMBDA / BI-QUOTES // STACKED TRIPLE CIRCLES / POT.

A third figure holds a diamond shape as MAN HOLDING DIAMOND (X 26), also enumerated as KP38 and W53.  This variation on the common theme is another singleton from Mohenjo daro (M-99).
Bar seal M-354 with inscription: MAN HOLDING TRIANGULAR DEE-SLASH /
BACK CEE & CEE / BI-QUOTES //CAGED FISH UNDER CHEVRON /
BELTED OVERLAPPING CIRCLES / QUINT-FORK / CUP ON 3 PRONGS UNDER CHEVRON / POT.

Following these rare signs is MAN HOLDING TRIANGULAR DEE-SLASH (X 27), apparently a variant of the more curvilinear IX 29.  Only Wells lists this variant independently (W26), which he finds three times at Mohenjo daro.
Bar seal M-383 with inscription: MAN HOLDING FOUR QUOTES / DOUBLE GRIDS (3 X 3).

The last of this type of combination sign is MAN HOLDING FOUR QUOTES (X 28), also known as KP30, W25, and Fs (A-1 + P-6).  In Fairservis’ interpretation, this ligature represents the MAN as “ruler, sovereign” pluralized by the four additional strokes, i.e., “rulers.”  Wells considers there to be three occurrences, two from Mohenjo daro and one from Harappa.  At the latter site, however, the instance he cites is one of two that show FOUR POSTS alongside MAN HOLDING POST, not quite the same thing. 
African rock art from southern Niger depicting a mounted warrior with lance and shield (LeQuellec 2004: 58, fig. 3).

None of these figures holding an object has a close parallel in contemporary scripts.  But in Egyptian hieroglyphs there are several broadly similar types that include a man holding or using an implement.  These include A10 (seated man holding an oar), A12 (seated man holding bow and quiver of arrows), A14 (man sometimes shown seated, gripping an ax embedded in his head), A19 (man bent over, holding onto a walking stick), A24 (standing man using both hands to grip a shorter stick than the previous), A34 (man using a tall pestle in a mortar), and A35 (man holding onto the glyph for a building).  Others also appear in this script, but again, none is a particularly close match for the specific signs found in the Indus script.
Hohokam petroglyph depicting a possible dance (Noble 1991: 64).

Occasionally, an author finds great significance in the apparent similarities between Indus signs showing such human-like figures holding one or another object, on the one hand, and roughly similar figures some other script found far away.  For example, the symbols on the rongorongo boards of Easter Island also take the form of human-like figures holding one or another object.  This Easter Island script dates to over two millennia after the end of Indus script and occurs thousands of miles away.  Thus, there can hardly be a direct link.  As Richard McDorman points out, the similarities between the two scripts are surely due to universal tendencies (2009).  That is, people everywhere have a strong tendency to depict people.  And people everywhere tend to have a head and four limbs, often using one of those limbs (typically a hand) to hold something.  The resulting similarity in symbols is due to the underlying similarity of people. It is not an indication that the Indus script gave rise directly to some other script or set of symbols.  This seems obvious to many people, but clearly it is not obvious enough to everybody.
A man as depicted in the Naxi script, a proto-writing system of a minority group of China.

The ancient Chinese also depicted people in a simplified, schematic form, often holding something intended as an offering.  Examples from bronze votive vessels are shown in Wieger’s book (1967: 361-385).  The filial son offers strings of cowrie shells, offerings of meat, and so on, in each case represented by a stick figure with one or more objects in hand. 
Detail from the great overhang of Songo in Mali, showing man with inverted "L" shape in hand,
center left (LeQuellec 2004: 60).

African rock art includes similar depictions of schematic men holding schematically depicted objects, e.g., a feathered horseman with a lance and shield from Niger (LeQuellec 2004: 58), a man holding a tall, inverted “L” shape on the great overhang of Songo in Mali (2004: 60-61), flat-headed stick figures holding a variety of shapes on the “stone of the fetish” on the banks of the Zaire River (2004: 86-87).
Panel of Texas rock art, with very small anthropomorph holding a stick near the center,
above the head of the odd quadruped (Newcomb and Kirkland 1996: 192, Pl. 142, no. 20-K).

Almost equally schematic anthropomorphs frequently appear in the rock art of North America and they, too, often hold one or more objects in one or both hands (e.g., Newcomb and Kirkland 1996: 156, Pl. 109, no. 8 and p. 160, Pl. 112, no. 6).  In such cases, the objects are often not readily identifiable.
Seal C-20 with inscription: STRIPED HORN / CIRCLE / SINGLE POST / CIRCLE / BEARER (X29"j").

Returning to the Indus signs, the BEARER occurs in a ten-stroke form (X 29), with horizontal lines for arms, or with arms describing a “V” shape (Wells’ variants “j” and “e,” respectively).  This relatively common sign occurs 35 times, according to Wells at Mohenjo daro and Harappa.  Wells cites other variants also occurring at these sites, as well as at Lothal, Kalibangan, Dholavira, and Allahdino (though I see seven instances of the straight-armed “j” at Mohenjo daro, Harappa, Chanhujo daro, and Dholavira, along with two occurrences of “e” at Mohenjo daro and Harappa only).  This symbol appears in one form or another in other lists as KP1, W4, and Fs A-7. 
Detail from seal M-834 with inscription: VEE IN DIAMOND / BI-QUOTES //
CEE / MALLET / TRI-FORK / BEARER (X29"e").

Fairservis identifies it as a man with a carrying pole to which looped cords are attached, meaning “watchman.”  Others may see the ovals typically attached to the “carrying pole” as representing pots.  But Fairservis states:

It should be noted that the loops on the carrying pole have often been referred to as vessels or jars, or loads of some kind.  However, there are no vessels of the type depicted in the glyph known for the Harappan civilization.  As to the loops representing “loads’, since the kinds of loads is not depicted and carrying loops are necessary for suspending any load, we appear to be on safe ground in assuming that what is represented is the means of suspension, not what is suspended (1992: 43-44).

He sees the symbol as indicating “one who carries a club” (like one who carries a carrying yoke) as being akin to “Powerful Guardian” or “Watchman,” without distinguishing variations with arms of one type or another (or even without arms).

As one can readily see, all the signs in the Indus script are either abstract or highly schematized depictions, so it seems reasonable to assume the ovals in the “bearer” signs are also schematic depictions.  One need not find a round pot or a jar shaped like a pointed oval to see such vessels represented in these signs.  After all, humans are considerably more complex in reality than are the stick figures in the script.  Why should the loads carried on the yoke be depicted more realistically than the fellow carrying them?  Anyway, there are in fact roundish forms among the various types of pottery excavated at Harappan sites (Kenoyer 1998: 154-155 and Possehl 2002: 143).
Detail from seal H-57 with inscription: STACKED TWELVE BETWEEN CEES /
CHEVRON-HATTED BEARER (note the latter is armless and also without a body).

Whether or not one agrees with Fairservis, the last of the anthropomorphic signs of ten strokes is CHEVRON HATTED BEARER (X 30), an armless variety (and very few armless individuals can have made use of shoulder yokes).  This particular version appears only in Wells’ list (W28), where it shows up in three variations.  Two of these are from Mohenjo daro (Wells “a” being M-1305, though I must disagree; his “b” M-899).  The third is from Harappa (Wells’ variant “c” on H-57).  The last variant not only lacks arms, it also lacks a body.  The “legs” come down directly from the yoke.  So much for realism!
(In all cases, artwork is by the author of this post, with images considerably smoothed and differently colored than the originals.)

REFERENCES

Fairservis, Walter A. 1992. The Harappan civilization and its writing: A model for the decipherment of the Indus script. Leiden: E.J. Brill.

Gardiner, Sir Alan. 1927 and 1976. Egyptian grammar: Being an introduction to the study of hieroglyphs (3rd ed.). Oxford: Griffith Institute and Ashmolean Museum.

Joshi, Jagat Pati and Asko Parpola. 1987. Corpus of Indus seals and inscriptions. 1. Collections in India. Helsinki: Suomalainen Tiedeakatemia.

Koskenniemi, Kimmo and Asko Parpola. 1982. A concordance to the texts in the Indus script. Helsinki: Department of Asian and African Studies, University of Helsinki.

LeQuellec, Jean-Loic. 2004. Rock art in Africa: Mythology and legend. Paris: Flammarion.

McDorman, Richard E. 2009. Universal iconography in writing systems: Evidence and explanation in the Easter Island and Indus Valley script. Amazon Kindle edition.

Menninger, Karl. 1969. Number words and number symbols: A cultural history of numbers. Transl. Paul Broneer. Cambridge: Massachusetts Institute of Technology. (Orig. published 1958 as Zahlwort und Ziffer by Vandenhoeck and Ruprecht).

Newcomb, W.W. Jr. and Forrest Kirkland. 1996. The rock art of Texas Indians. Austin: University of Texas.

Noble, David G. 1991. The Hohokam: Ancient people of the desert. Santa Fe, New Mexico: School of American Research.

Shah, Sayid Ghulam Mustafa and Asko Parpola 1991. Corpus of Indus seals and Inscriptions. 2. Collections in Pakistan. Helsinki: Suomalainen Tiedeakatemia.

Wells, Bryan. 1998. An introduction to Indus writing: A thesis. Available at:


Yang, Xiaoneng, ed. 1999. The golden age of Chinese archaeology: Celebrated discoveries from the People’s Republic of China. London and New Haven: Yale University.

Proto-Elamite from http://cdli.ucla.edu/wiki/doku.php/linear-elamite

Tuesday, July 26, 2011


VARIATIONS ON SIMPLE SCHEMES
Seal H-473 with inscription: STRIPED BOWTIE WITH EXTRA RIBBON / BATTERY EXIT / VEE IN DIAMOND.

We have seen various “bowtie” forms in the Indus script, made of two triangles with apex toward each other (or an “hourglass” form turned on its side).  Today’s post begins with consideration of a new type, STRIPED BOWTIE WITH EXTRA RIBBON (X 17), seen elsewhere as KP226, W451, and Fs M-4.  Fairservis sees this as a depiction of a drum with three parts, defining it as “all, whole.”  Wells finds five instances, all but one from Mohenjo daro.  I see as many as 10 altogether, though still all are from Mohenjo daro but one (H-473).
Proto-cuneiform sign KAD4~a, "to tie, bind together," an analog to Indus X 17.

Bowtie or hourglass shapes are common as decorative motifs outside the Indus Valley.  But as a sign, an elaborated "bowtie" occurs less often.  Proto-cuneiform does provide a distant parallel with KAD4~a, a “bowtie” with three stripes in each triangle and three horizontal strokes to the left.  It came to mean “to tie, bind together.”
Broken and abraded seal H-474 with partial inscription: CEE (?) / STRIPED FAT CHEVRON / FAT CHEVRON / ?
(note the presence of two types of "chevron" in this inscription, an indication that these are independent signs).

There have also been a couple of chevron-like shapes in previous posts.  The second sign discussed today is STRIPED FAT CHEVRON (X 18).  It appears in the literature as KP195 and Fs K-2, as well as two separate enumerations in Wells’ list: W260 and W421.  Fairservis sees the sign as a representing a measure, or something akin to a modern ruler or yardstick.  He suggests it was used to indicate measures of cloth.  Wells shows a ten-stroke version with rounded ends which is a singleton from Mohenjo daro.  He also includes a version with squared off ends, this one drawn with twelve strokes.  The latter occurs four times, twice each at Mohenjo daro and Harappa.
Two proto-cuneiform parallels to Indus X 18: ERIN, "cedar tree/wood" (above) and LA~e, "abundance" (below).

Proto-cuneiform provides a number of similar signs, including ERIN, “cedar tree or wood,” LA~e, “abundance; wealth; bliss, happiness,” and TUN3~b, “pocket, pouch, bag; wrap; leek; stomach; lip; rim.”  These symbols vary in the number and placement of the internal stripes, as well as the orientation of the overall shape.  However, none of them stand with a peak upward like a chevron, as the Indus sign does.
Seal M-241 with inscription: FOOTED EX / EXIT / POTTED ONE / OVERLAPPING CIRCLES /
TWO POSTS / POT / MAN (the last sign is either incomplete in the original or half abraded).

The following sign is a singleton I term FOOTED EX (X 19), also known as KP254 and W554.  The end of each arm of a simple “X” shape sports a very thin oval in this rare symbol from Mohenjo daro (M-241). 
A type of "footed" cross among proto-cuneiform signs, KIB, "an object that could be made of gold."

Such a symbol occurs rarely anywhere in this precise form, but variations on an “X” are extremely common.  Proto-cuneiform includes three cross shaped signs: the curved SZENNUR~b represents a highly schematic “plumtree”; the striped KESZ2 is a “knot” or “tether”; and only two “feet” appear on KIB, “an object that could be made of gold.”
Two elaborated crosses among the stamp seals of Altyn Depe (Masson 1988: Pl. XVI, nos. 2 and 6).

Adinkra "footed ex" design from West Africa (Visona et al 2001: 120).
Elaborated crosses and exes often appear on stamp seals from the Central Asian site of Altyn Depe, as well as on pottery.  The same may be said of pottery from New Mexico, made by Native Americans.  The West African Adinkra symbols include a cross-hatched “X” with rounded “feet.”  And the cross and “X” also appear in various elaborated forms in Nubian art, in what is now Sudan.
Modern pots with painted elaborations of "X" shapes from New Mexico (photo by author).

Nubian ceramic window grille in the form of an elaborated "X" from
the Church of the Granite Columns at Old Dongola (Welsby 2002: 222, fig. 89).

But X 19 in the Indus script is closest to an Old Chinese “footed ex” that represents the 10th heavenly stem, guei3 (Keightley 1978: 219).  This symbol is part of a date commonly found on "oracle bones" in ancient China, dating to the Shang period.  In later China, the 10 heavenly stems combine with the 12 earthly branches to form dates, as well as the 12 animals that are better known in the West.
Two variants of the Old Chinese "footed ex," guei3, 10th heavenly stem (Keightley 1978: 219).
Chinese oracle bone inscription, with guei3 at the top of the first and second columns
(from the right), giving the date of the crack-making / divining (Keightley 1978: 43).

Previously, I mentioned a “footed stool” element among Indus signs with “feet” to the right, as well as a reversed version with “feet” on the left.  We now consider the combination of these two, with the “feet” facing one another.  I call this ligature OPPOSED DOUBLE FOOTED STOOLS (X 20).  The individual elements appear in the Koskenniemi and Parpola list as KP230 and KP234, but not as a ligature.  Faiservis does not include the combination either.  Wells often enumerates doubled symbols independently and does so here: W452.  He finds five instances of the ligature, with three coming from Mohenjo daro, and one apiece from Lothal and Kot diji.  I see an additional occurrence from each of these locations, raising the total to eight.
Inscription on a bangle from Kot diji (Kd-8), reading from right: BLANKET WITH SIX TICKS /
STRIPED BOWTIE WITH TICK / BOAT / OPPOSED DOUBLE FOOTED STOOLS (highlighted) / POT (?).

In proto-Elamite there is a similar sign, with two “stools” placed together in such a fashion (M318).  In this area, however, the “stools” lack “feet.”
Detail from seal M-43 with inscription: HAIRY DIAMOND LOLLIPOP /
STACKED 12 / BI-QUOTES / DOT IN FISH / CRAB / POT.

The next Indus sign is a small diamond set atop a short “post,” with five prongs rising from the top: HAIRY DIAMOND LOLLIPOP (X 21), also known as W249.  In the Koskenniemi and Parpola list, this element appears as a pronged oval on a post (KP360).  But I see a diamond shape in the two instances that Wells lists (M-43 and M-1002).  The length of the prongs differs in these two examples, but Wells gives no indication of variants.
Two proto-cuneiform parallels to the Indus X 21: MASZ2 @ g " extispicy" (above) and SZUM, "saw, knife" (below).

Proto-cuneiform includes two rhomboid (or diamond-shaped) “lollies,” BU~b with two prongs on top, and MASZ2 @ g with six or seven off to one side.  The latter also has a cross-piece on the “stem.”  The former came to mean “to tear, cut off,” while the latter became, “extispicy (divination from entrails), omen; sacrificial animal.”  There is also a “lolly” with a round end, sporting three prongs: SZUM, “saw, knife, sickle with serrated edge.”  In each case, I would have thought the symbol depicted some type of plant, but none of these definitions supports such an interpretation.  This is one lesson that potential decipherers of Indus signs should take to heart.
Tablet H-959A and B with inscriptions: DIAMOND HEADED (?) HAIRY HUNCHBACK / POT / COMB (A side);
CUP / THREE POSTS (B side) (note that the "hunchback" is essentially the same as the "oval-headed" version).

The last Indus sign for today’s post is also a variation on a theme seen previously, DIAMOND HEADED HAIRY HUNCHBACK (X 22).  Fairservis notes only an “oval-headed” variation (E-5 + P-4), seeing it as a ligature of two or three simpler signs.  Combining the “bud” with the chevron, defined as “head,” and adding four strokes as a pluralizer, he derives the meaning, “cotton.”  Koskenniemi and Parpola also include only an “oval-headed” version (KP194).  Wells enumerates this angular variation separately (W82), although it is a singleton (H-959).  My own inclination is to consider this a slightly more angular variant of the eight-stroke, “oval-headed” sign.  It appears on a tablet rather than a seal, which often means slight variation in sign shape.
Proto-cuneiform DA~c, "arm; side," a very distant parallel to Indus X 22 with its prongs.

The closest analog I find among the proto-cuneiform signs is DA~c, a schematic representation of an arm, with prongs for fingers and thumb.  It came to mean “arm” (not surprisingly), but also “side; nearness.”  Despite the angular, diamond-shaped “head,” it still resembles depictions of the flute-playing deity of the American Southwest with feathers, Kokopelli (to give him his Hopi name).  This figure appears in Texas, New Mexico, Arizona, and Nevada, in rock art and elsewhere.  He also shows up in Navaho sand paintings, in a more elaborated form.

Hohokam version of the flute-playing god known as Kokopelli to the Hopi (Noble 1991: 52, from a ceramic bowl).

REFERENCES:

Keightley, David N. 1978. Sources of Shang History: The Oracle-Bone Inscriptions of Bronze Age China. Berkeley: University of California.

Masson, V.M. 1988. Altyn-Depe. Transl. Henry N. Michael. Philadelphia: University Museum of University of Pennsylvania.

Noble, David G. 1991. The Hohokam: Ancient People of the Desert. Santa Fe, New Mexico: School of American Research.

Visona, Monica B, Robin Poynor, Herbert M. Cole, and Michael D. Harris. 2001. A History of Art in Africa. Upper Saddle River, New Jersey: Prentice Hall and Harry N. Abrams.

Welsby, Derek A. 2002. The Medieval Kingdoms of Nubia: Pagans, Christians and Muslims along the Middle Nile. London: The British Museum.