Tuesday, January 11, 2011

Is There a Banyan Tree in the Indus Script?

In his book The Indus Script: A Positional-Statistical Approach, M. Korvink uses the term “banyan” for a sign that I call TRI-FORK TOPPED POT (2007: 28).  The sign resembles the letter “U” with trident-like projections at the tops of each side.  The sign appears in other writing on the Indus script with numerical designations (sign 332{a} in Koskenniemi and Parpola 1982: 21; sign 303 in Wells 1998: appendix; J-4 in Fairservis 1992: 173; my VI51, indicating that it is the fifty-first in my list of six-stroke signs).  Korvink notes that there are variants of this “banyan,” but does not show them.  He analyzes occurrences of his “banyan” based on information in I. Mahadevan’s concordance, to which I lack access.  Korvink also refers to inscriptions by the code numbers assigned to them in the same concordance, codes which do not match the item numbers in the Corpus of Indus Seals and Inscriptions (Vol. 1, Joshi and Parpola 1987; Vol. 2, Shah and Parpola 1991).  This makes my evaluation of his findings a bit difficult.  What Korvink has to say about other, better identified Indus signs seems valid, though, so it is worthwhile researching this topic further. 

Broken Indus seal L-64 with end of inscription: TRI-FORK TOPPED POT / POT.
Korvink states that the “banyan” occurs most frequently before the “jar” sign (2007: 30, 32).  The term “jar” is ambivalent.  It could refer to either my CUP or my POT (the “U” shaped sign or the “U” shape with double prongs on each side, respectively).  In this case, Korvink writes out several inscriptions, clarifying the reference as meaning POT.  POT is a terminal sign, in his analysis, as is the “banyan.”  Other terminals include MAN, SPEAR, COMB, and various types of BEARER (my terms, not his).  He subdivides the terminal class (as he does his prefix class) into constants and variables.  An inscription may or may not have a terminal, so, in that sense, the whole terminal is variable.  For Korvink, a variable is a sign that may or may not appear alongside a constant, but it will not occur unless there is another terminal sign following it.  In contrast, the constant may appear  in the terminal alone, unaccompanied by another terminal.  Thus, one finds inscription with and without terminals.  And in those inscriptions that do contain terminals, constants sometimes appear with and sometimes without variables, whereas variables appear only with constants, never without them. 
Seal Nd-1 with inscription: CIRCLED VEE / BI-QUOTES // STRIPED TRIANGLE / TRIPLE TRIANGLES / BOAT / SKEWERED CHEVRON / TRI-FORK TOPPED POT / POT.
Prefixes, like terminals, include constants and variables.  In the case of the prefix, the constant sign does not occur in initial position, but causes the variable to precede it.  Thus, a constant must follow a variable, but a particular constant is not invariably paired with the same variable.  The constants are few: SINGLE QUOTE, DOUBLE QUOTE, PINCH.  The variables, on the other hand, are many and often may occur with more than one constant.  Further, the constant does not occur outside this end-of-prefix position.  However, a sign that sometimes occurs in a prefix as a variable may also occur in medial or final position in an inscription, as long as the constant is not there.  The situation is a bit more complicated than that, but that is the gist of Korvink’s thesis. 
In the terminal portion of the inscription, the signs follow a certain sequence.  Korvink lays out this sequence in the form of a grid.  From beginning to end, the terminal follows the following sequence: (1) BANYAN, (2) COMB (“b” position), (3) SPEAR, (4) POT, (5) MAN, (6) CHEVRON-HATTED BEARER, (7) POT HATTED BEARER, (8) (SIMPLE) BEARER, (9) COMB (“a” position).  No inscription contains all of these terminals.  Typically, an inscription has one, two, or three terminals in sequence, but that may be the limit. 
In Korvink’s grid, the “banyan” (shown as my TRI-FORK TOPPED POT) occurs once apiece before a number of terminal constants: the simple BEARER, the CHEVRON HATTED BEARER + POT HATTED BEARER pair, the COMB, and the MAN.  The “banyan” appears before the SPEAR eight times.  The most frequent pairing is before the POT, which appears 110 times.  In all, the “banyan” occurs 118 times in the corpus of inscriptions, according to Korvink’s figures, which do not add up, to my mind (110 + 8 + (4 x 1) = 122).  Each of the signs that follows the “banyan” is a constant terminal that occurs elsewhere without the preceding “banyan.”  The “banyan,” though, does not occur as a terminal without a following constant (Korvink’s analysis again). 
Seal M-678 (detail) with inscription: STRIPED BISECTED TRIANGLE / SINGLE POST / BI-QUOTES // CIRCLED E TRI-FORK / CAGED FISH / STRIPED TRIANGLE / SIX QUOTES / FLANGE TOPPED POT / POT.
Note that, by this analysis, the opposite sequence should not occur, i.e., one of the constant terminals should not precede the variable, “banyan.”  However, Korvink admits that there is one inscription with the “banyan” in which the reverse order does appear, i.e., POT + “banyan” (which I find to be on a tablet from Harappa, H-302).  This inscription has a medial portion preceding the terminal section and another terminal sign following the out-of-sequence “banyan,” i.e., COMB (Joshi and Parpola 1987: 225).  The inscription reads from right to left: BI-RAKE / FISH / POT / TRI-FORK TOPPED POT / COMB.  Here, the terminal portion contains three signs (POT / TRI-FORK TOPPED POT / COMB), following two medial signs, hence, this instance cannot be a matter of reading in the wrong direction.  Korvink suggests that it could easily be due to “scribal error” (2007: 30).
In one other anomalous inscription, M-1103 on a seal from Mohenjo daro, the “banyan” occurs in medial position.  Korvink does not give an explanation for this, but it is presumably similar to that described earlier in his book for signs in the prefix.  When variables appear in the prefix, e.g., CARTWHEEL, CIRCLED VEE, or VEE IN DIAMOND preceding the common constant BI-QUOTES, both signs are classified as parts of the prefix.  In each case, the first sign is the variable and the second the constant.  Each of these variable signs also occurs outside the prefix, i.e., without the BI-QUOTES following it.  His explanation is that the presence of the constant is what causes the variable to take the preceding position (2007: 22). 
Seal K-43 with inscription (reading from top to bottom and left to right): CRAB / REVERSED CRAB / POTTED TWO //
POTTED TWO / BARBELLS / STACKED THREE // TRI-FORK TOPPED POT / POT.
Presumably, there is a similar explanation for the terminal portion of inscriptions.  The constant in the terminal causes the variable to take its position.  In the case of inscriptions other than M-1103, the POT (or SPEAR or MAN) causes the “banyan” to take the first position in the terminal, immediately after the rest of the inscription.  But when the POT (or SPEAR or MAN) is not there, the “banyan” can appear elsewhere.  As a result of this principle, in M-1103 the TRI-FORK TOPPED POT is in medial position: BLANKET / CUPPED STRIPED SPOON / TRI-FORK TOPPED POT / STRIPED MALLET / CARTWHEEL / SINGLE QUOTE (reading from left to right; Shah and Parpola 1991: 116).  In another inscription, on seal K-40 from Kalibangan, the same sign is in final position: FIVE TOED FOOT / BATTERY / DOUBLE CIRCLES / VEE IN DIAMOND / BI-QUOTES / TRI-FORK TOPPED POT (left to right again; Joshi and Parpola 1987: 305).  This inscription is analyzed as comprising a prefix of five signs ending with the constant BI-QUOTES, followed by a medial section comprised of a single sign, the TRI-FORK TOPPED POT.  Although this sign is the last one in the inscription, it is not a terminal element in this case, because it lacks a companion sign that can be classified as a terminal constant.
Thus far, Korvink’s analysis seems valid.  I do have a minor quibble, based on terminology.  While Korvink does not state that these kinds of positional regularities necessarily indicate grammatical elements, these seem to be implied by the terms he uses, especially by the word “prefix.”  To his credit, he notes that previous researchers clearly confused these two levels of analysis.  He also makes a case for not making this mistake and states that his analysis is only positional.  I think his case would be improved by using somewhat different terminology which would not seem to imply a grammatical analysis.  In studies of proto-Elamite, a contemporary symbol system, Damerow and Englund use the term “header” for a group of symbols that appear at the beginning of some texts (the “hairy triangle”; 1989).  I think it would be better to use this same term in place of “prefix.”  That suggests the opposite term “footer” instead of “terminal.”
In my view there are a couple of other anomalies.  Although Korvink does not say this, I get the impression from reading his book that he saw the medial segment of the inscription as the one part that was obligatory, while both his prefix and terminal were optional.  Other scholars, who claim to have discerned the meaning of specific signs (something Korvink does not do), certainly claim that the terminals are suffixes.  Neither of these appears to be correct.  According to my own observations, although there is some validity to Korvink’s three segments, an inscription may contain any one of these.  In other words, all three are optional.  The medial segment is there most often.  If we abbreviate the three sections as P (for prefix), M (for medial), and T (for terminal), I can state my findings more succinctly and clearly.  I see inscriptions of the following types: P, M, T; PM, MT, PT; PMT, and longer inscriptions that combine two of these (e.g., PMTM and so on).  The odd ones that don’t seem to follow Korvink’s analysis are not particularly common, but they are there.  Korvink himself specifically notes some of these instances.  Other researchers often fail to account for anomalies, such as instances where described as a suffix occurs alone.  Suffixes should not do that.  At the very least, such a sign would seem to require at least two meanings, only one of which can be suffixal.
That aside, I still need to determine which of the other signs in various lists fall under the rubric of “banyan.”  Korvink states that the latter sign occurs 118 times in the corpus of inscriptions, based on Mahadevan’s figures.  Wells gives the frequency of the TRI-FORK TOPPED POT as 30 occurrences, so there must be a large number of other inscriptions not accounted for.  The first possibility for a variant “banyan” is my BI-FORK TOPPED POT (Koskenniemi and Parpola 332{c}, Wells 305, Fairservis J-9, my VI53).  This is another “U” shape with only two prongs at the top of each “arm” similar to the letter “Y.”  This is almost certainly one of  the “banyan” variants, since a few inscriptions on tablets are duplicates but for this difference.  For example, on tablet H-879 the inscription reads (from left to right): STRIPED DOOR & KNOB / BI-FORK TOPPED POT / POT (V) / COMB (5).  The next tablet, H-880, reads (left to right): STRIPED DOOR & KNOB / TRI-FORK TOPPED POT / POT (V) / COMB (6).  Next is H-881 with the same inscription as 879 (with BI-FORK TOPPED POT, though the COMB has only 4 teeth now).  H-882 duplicates H-880 (with TRI-FORK TOPPED POT, plus the COMB has only 4 teeth).  The next one, H-883, might have been a duplicate, since it ends with POT / COMB.  But the first part is broken off.  A tiny bit at the top of the right side remains of the previous sign.  But it is not enough to clearly determine whether it had two or three prongs.  My guess would be that it is another TRI-FORK TOPPED POT.  Either way, it fits the general pattern of these others.  These near duplicates strongly suggest that the two symbols, BI-FORK TOPPED POT and TRI-FORK TOPPED POT, are variants of one sign, the “banyan.”  When Korvink uses the term variant, this does not indicate that these two symbols necessarily have the same lexical meaning (footnote 2007: 30).  Such replacement patterns may indicate this, but it is also possible that the symbols only served a similar syntactical function.  As Wells observes, this kind of replacement pattern could also indicate that the lexical meanings of the two signs are in the same semantic class (1998: REF).  For example, words (or signs) for two different types of grain, such as barley and wheat, could be expected in the same or similar contexts in an inscription.
Wells gives the frequency of the BI-FORK TOPPED POT as 23 occurrences.  Adding these together with the 30 he lists for the TRI-FORK TOPPED POT yields a total number of “banyan” occurrences of 53.  This is still a good ways short of Korvink’s 118 occurrences.  Once I obtained the first two volumes of the Corpus, I made my own count of each of the symbols.  I first devised an identifying name for each sign and then wrote out in transcribed form all of the inscriptions that I could read (some are illegible).  I entered this information into a computer database in Microsoft Excel, which allows me to search out and identify the appearances of the signs.  My list of inscriptions containing the BI-FORK TOPPED POT and TRI-FORK TOPPED POT follow:
TRI-FORK TOPPED POT / POT: Banawali B-31 {broken pot shard, tops only, R-L}; Harappa H-13, 30, 101, 161, 287, 302 {*reverse order!}, 469, 593, 599, 852, 880, 882, 903, 973; Kalibangan K-24, 43 {over pot}; Lothal L-5, 64 {? broken}, 95 {? broken}, 112 {? odd, tri- + post topped pot?}, 211; Mohenjo daro M-47, 149, 239, 245, 275, 284, 314 {medial? in long inscription}, 456, 733, 735, 843 {?broken; final sign prob. Bearer}, 862, 1010 {?broken}, 1070 {? or tri- + post topped pot}, 1071, 1078 {?br}, 1079, 1100, 1155, 1163, 1177, 1400B {?unclear}; Nindowari damb Nd-1 = 45 subtotal with 8 uncertain, followed by POT
OTHERS: TRI-FORK TOPPED POT (alone); M-1103 {medial, no pot}, M-1579 (alone on bangle); K40 {FINAL, no pot}; Kot Diji Kd-10 {? broken pot shard, unclear fragment beside clear}) = subtotal 3 +/- 1
BANYAN “A” total 48 +/- 9
BI-FORK TOPPED POT) / POT: Harappa H-199, 362, 376 (?), 879, 881, 912, 975, 994; Lothal L-14, 278; Lohunjo daro Lh-1; Mohenjo daro M-44, 55(?), 112, 162, 165, 198, 221, 274, 623 (?), 646, 754, 758, 818, 859, 957, 986, 1019, 1602 (?); Rakhi garhi Rgr-1; Rahman dheri Rhd-238 (?) = 31 +/- 5 subtotal BANYAN “Bb”; BI-FORK TOPPED POT / SPEAR: Mohenjo daro M-0026 = 1 subtotal BANYAN “Ba”
BANYAN “B” total 32 +/- 5
[COMPOSITES, NOT BANYAN, and LIGATURES: bi-rake & trident prong yu / pot (H-0182, H-0203, H-0365, M-0543, M-0654, M-0688, M-1181, C-0022) = 8 of type A [NOT BANYAN]; bi-rake & flange prong yu / 4 toe foot [medial ?] / pot / man (M-0899) = 1 of type C [NOT BANYAN]; bi-rake & wy prong yu (or bi-fork prong yu) / pot (C-0021) = 1 of type B [NOT BANYAN]; bi-rake & (?) prong yu / pot (?) (H-0148, H-0999); trident prong yu with attached post / pot (M-0622) [LIGATURED BANYAN “A”]  = total ODD POTS (BI-RAKE ATTACHED TO x); H-300 (Loop-topped DUBYA) [are Dubyas also Banyans?]; M-234 is not DUBYA (or CUP) but CORN HOLDER; M-594 prob. POTTED ONE(broken) / zee / crossroads ex / pot]
This brings a possible total of “banyan” signs (A and B above) to a maximum of 70, using my figures.  There remains a substantial gap between this frequency and that cited by Korvink.  Another sign, the FLANGE TOPPED POT, may be a third variant of Korvink’s “banyan” (Koskenniemi and Parpola 332{b}, Wells 306, Fairservis J-7, my VI54).  Like BANYANS “A” and “B,” this symbol also occurs most frequently preceding POT, a fact that identifies it as another variable in a compound terminal. 
flange prong yu (FLANGE TOPPED POT) / POT: Harappa H-47, 58, 477 {striped, in prefix without pot}, 743, 744, 745, 746; Mohenjo daro M-30, 394 {striped}, 397, 551, 552, 553, 554, 555, 556, 557, 558, 559, 560, 561, 562, 563, 564, 565 {15 duplicates}, 678 {?}, 707 {?}, 1275, 1327 {?broken, no pot}, 1503, 1504, 1505, 1506, 1507, 1508, 1509, 1510, 1511, 1512, 1513 {11 duplicates}, 1650 {rod, reading right to left} = BANYAN “Ca” subtotal 40 +/- 3, “Cb” subtotal 1]
BANYAN “C” total 41 +/- 3
In one of the inscriptions including the FLANGE TOPPED POT, the possible “banyan” appears in the absence of a following POT.  The inscription reads, from left to right: SPACESHIP / STRIPED FLANGE TOPPED POT / STRIPED MALLET / SINGLE QUOTE / MAN WITH DOUBLE ANKLETS.  In this case, H-477, the sign in question is in the prefix, since it appears among the symbols preceding SINGLE QUOTE.  Presumably, the absence of the POT is what “allows” the supposed “banyan” here to leave the terminal portion of the inscription.  The other STRIPED FLANGE TOPPED POT appears immediately before the POT, as expected for a variant of the “banyan” (M-394) 
I count a maximum total of 48 TRI-FORK TOPPED POTS (BANYAN “A”), 32 BI-FORK TOPPED POTS (BANYAN “B”), and 41 FLANGE TOPPED POTS (BANYAN “C”) of which 17 are questionable.  Adding these together yields a minimum total of 104, deleting all uncertain readings, and a maximum total of 121 “banyans,” assuming all uncertain readings are accepted.  Two further questionable possibilities include a sign I call EL TOPPED POT (Rhd-169 and Rhd-170 from Rahman-Dheri).  These are rather different graphically from all previous examples in that they are angular, with square bottoms.  There is a single horizontal prong extending outward on each side, an element I am terming an EL.  Each of these two examples appears on a pot shard, where it might be intended as a slightly abbreviated POT (a sign which normally has two such prongs on each side).  If this is the case, they cannot be variants of the “banyan.”  A third possibility is that these only exist as pot marks and are intended as something different from any other sign.  Including them as additional variants brings the maximum total to 122, while leaving them out of consideration keeps the minimum total of “banyans” at 104.  The total number cited by Korvink, 118 occurrences, falls within this range of possibilities (i.e., 118 ≈ 104-122).  We can safely assume that at least a few of questionable items are misidentified in my maximum total, accounting for the difference.
One has to wonder, though, whether there is any way to test my conclusions.  Perhaps the form of certain ligatures (composite symbols made up of parts of two or more other symbols) involving these proposed “banyans” will tend to confirm the hypothesis that there are three or four variants of this one sign.  There are two occurrences of FAT CHEVRON IN TRI-FORK TOPPED POT, K-18 from Kalibangan and H-484 from Harappa, the latter broken and somewhat uncertain.  Originally, I thought the broken occurrence at Harappa might indicate a CARTWHEEL inside, since only the peaked, bisected top is visible.  But there is no other CARTWHEEL in such a position, while there is another FAT CHEVRON.  Hence, the latter now seems more likely.  Still, there are many signs that occur only once, in this script, so each of these composite signs might be a singleton.  As it happens, there is no variant *FAT CHEVRON IN BI-FORK TOPPED POT, nor is there a *FAT CHEVRON IN FLANGE TOPPED POT.  Thus, this ligature cannot help determine the likelihood that the three possible BANYANS really are variants of one sign.

Seal H-14 (detail, with bovine horn at left) with inscription: DOUBLE STACKED TWELVE / RAKE / PINCH // WHISKERED FISH / BI-RAKE AND BI-FORK TOPPED POT // POT. 

Another ligature has a BI-RAKE on the left, a vertical stem beneath two comb-like elements stacked one over the other (the whole thing resembling a telephone pole with two crosspieces).  This element is attached to another by a curving line to the right.  The part on the right is the focus of our investigation at this point.  In my terms, there are three variations on this theme: (1) BI-RAKE & TRI-FORK TOPPED POT, (2) BI-RAKE & BI-FORK TOPPED POT, and (3) BI-RAKE & FLANGE TOPPED POT.  All 16 instances of such ligatures occur either just before POT or next to a break where there could have originally been such a sign at the end:

BI-RAKE & TRI-FORK TOPPED POT: Mohenjo daro M-5, 118, 162, 706, 750*, 780, 804(?), 903, 924, 958, 979, 1146; Harappa H-14 = total 13 +/- 2 LIGATURE “A” < BI-RAKE + BANYAN “A”
BI-RAKE & BI-FORK TOPPED POT: Mohenjo daro M-705 = total 1 LIGATURE “B” < BI-RAKE + BANYAN “B”
BI-RAKE & STRIPED FLANGE TOPPED POT: Mohenjo daro M-360; Harappa H-478(?) = total 2 +/- 1 LIGATURE “C” < BI-RAKE + BANYAN “C”
BI-RAKE & BANYAN LIGATURE total 16 +/- 3
(* M-750 actually has a QUAD-FORK top on the right; cf. H-1010 BI-FORK & QUAD-FORK TOPPED POT which may even be a QUINT-FORK, as the reading is somewhat uncertain.)
The fact that there appear to be three variants of the BI-RAKE AND BANYAN LIGATURE, along with the fact that each of the BANYAN variants appears in this ligature, tend to support the identification of these three types of BANYAN.  The hypothesis is not proved, as the total number of ligatures is extremely small.  It is only tentatively supported.  Future discoveries may provide additional information on this topic.

Moving now to the subject of parallel symbols in other cultural spheres, I find few examples.  For the TRI-FORK TOPPED POT (BANYAN "A"), which I enumerate VI51, proto-Elamite provides the only such parallel.  The Iranian symbol is "V" shaped, as is occasionally the case with Indus signs that are more frequently "U" shaped.  At the ends of the prongs, the proto-Elamite sign has a similar trident-like element (M061, see reference below for the website).
Proto-Elamite sign M061.

 The "Y" shaped prongs of the BI-FORK TOPPED POT (my VI53) sometimes resemble the hands of the anthropomorphic figures found on a number of seals.  This calls to mind the Egyptian ka, one aspect of the human soul, which was written with a hieroglyph formed of two arms reaching upward (D28 in Gardiner's list).  The base of the glyph is squared off, unlike the Indus sign, but the simplified hands are quite similar.
Proto-Elamite sign M285, a parallel to Indus sign BI-FORK TOPPED POT.

The third apparent variant (FLANGE TOPPED POT, VI54) lacks a proto-Elamite parallel.  It does resemble a proto-cuneiform sign, however (ZATU831).  The meaning of this symbol is unknown, which is the case with most proto-Elamite signs as well.  A second parallel occurs in Luwian hieroglyphs.  The symbol here represents a syllable, sa, and appears upside-down compared to the Indus sign (Cambel 1999: 90).

Proto-cuneiform sign ZATU831, parallel to Indus sign FLANGE TOPPED POT.



REFERENCES:

Cambel, Halet. 1999. Corpus of Hieroglyphic Inscriptions, Vol. II, Karatepe-Aslantas. New York: Walter de Gruyter.

Damerow, Peter and Robert Englund. 1989. The Proto-Elamite Texts from Tepe Yahya. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.

Fairservis, Walter. 1992. The Harappan Civilization and its Writing: A Model for the Decipherment of the Indus Script. Leiden: E.J. Brill.

Joshi, Jagat Pati and Asko Parpola, eds. 1987. Corpus of Indus Seals and Inscriptions 1. Collections in India. Helsinki: Suomalainen Tiedeakatemia.

Korvink, Michael. 2007. The Indus Script: A Positional-Statistical Approach.  Gilund: Amazon.com.

Koskenniemi, Kimmo and Asko Parpola. 1982. A Concordance to the Texts in the Indus Script. Helsinki: Department of Asian and African Studies, University of Helsinki.

Shah, Sayid Ghulam Mustafa and Asko Parpola, eds. 1991. Corpus of Indus Seals and Inscriptions 2. Collections in Pakistan. Helsinki: Suomalainen Tiedeakatemia.

Proto-cuneiform sign list online:
http://www.cdli.ucla.edu/tools/SignLists/protocuneiform/archsigns.html

Proto-Elamite sign list online:
http://cdli.ucla.edu/wiki/doku.php/linear-elamite

Thursday, January 6, 2011

Three Variations on the Indus 'Man' Sign

In the following, I discuss three Indus signs that are variations on the basic MAN (V23).  The first of these appears to be this same MAN standing on a horizontal base and positioned upside-down.  Due to this resemblance, I term the sign DOWN MAN ON BASE (VI47).  It appears only in one of the lists, that of Wells, where it receives two different identifying numbers: W48 and W57.  Each of these instances is a singleton, the first appearing at Mohenjo daro (M-306) and the second at Chandigarh (Ch-3).  I prefer to group the two as variants of a single sign, “A” and “B” respectively.  I do not think they really represent humans, especially in the case of the “B” variant, which has a very long “head” or stem.  It is more likely that they represent flowers.

Seal M-306 with inscription: VEE IN DIAMOND / DOWN MAN ON BASE / POTTED ONE / PACMAN / CRAB / POT / TRIPLE BRICK (smoothing of image and coloring added by author).
Parallels to this sign are frequent, a fact that I find surprising.  There is a slight resemblance to the Egyptian hieroglyph that supposedly represents the bicornuate uterus of a heifer (F45).  If we wish to consider the Indus sign as actually representing a human, then for comparison there is also a glyph of an upside-down man (A29).  It is a determinative in a word meaning “be upside-down.”  The latter glyph does not actually resemble the Indus sign, though.


Pot shard Ch-3 with DOWN MAN ON BASE (coloring and smoothing of image added) -- note long "head."
 Old Chinese presents a much closer analogy in the character zi3, “a new-born child, swathed up...By extension, disciple; then, a sage, a teacher, because the ancient Emperors, in order to honour them, called them sons” (Wieger 1965: 233).  In its original form, the Chinese character has a round head and the arms are a curved line, so that the Indus sign resembles an angular version of this.  It is interesting to note that this same ancient character appears upside-down in the character that means “birth.”  Another anthropomorphic character occasionally occurs upside-down, early on: “In some very rare but most precious figures, the deceased Ancestor is represented diving, head foremost, from heavens above, towards the hand of his offering son” (1965: 370).  This ancestral figure has now become the character tian1, “heaven, sky.”

Chinese oracle-bone variants
of zi3, "child."
A closer parallel graphically than any anthropomorphic character occurs in the calendrical character xin, which looks essentially the same as one identified by Wieger as qian2, “to offend a superior...; offence, fault, crime...By extension, to attack” (1965: 249).  In addition, the abstract bu2 is very similar, indicating “a bird that rises...straight towards the skies...now an adverb of negation” (1965: 302).

Oracle-bone variants of xin or qian2, "to offend."
But the closest in form to the Indus sign is one found in proto-cuneiform, identified as GU.  It came to mean “string; flax; needle.”  This sign is identical to the Indus sign except for its horizontal position, a common feature.  Doubled, the proto-cuneiform sign becomes SUH3, which came to signify “chaos, disorder.” 
Two variants of oracle-bone bu2, "not."
Nearly the same sign as GU is one that appears in doubled form in proto-Elamite, but with the “head” on the opposite side and the “arms” angled away from this “head” rather than toward it (M127 + M127).  Despite the designation for the proto-Elamite sign, it does not appear singly in the list of signs (i.e., M127 is not listed as an independent sign).  It may be relevant to observe another similar sign in proto-Elamite (M099).  It is closer to the Indus BOWTIE, with the addition of a stroke crossing at the point where the apexes of the two triangles come together.
The final proto-Elamite example is identical in form to a symbol found in west Africa, the Adinkra dono ntoaso (Willis 1998: 92).  This African motif is positioned vertically, unlike the proto-Elamite example, and means “double dono,” referring to a particular type of drum.

Indus seal C-30 with inscription: STACKED FIVE / LOOP ARMED MAN HOLDING SLASH /
CARTWHEEL BETWEEN DOUBLE POSTS (smoothing of image and coloring added).

Inscription on copper object: LOOP ARMED MAN HOLDING BACKSLASH /
CARTWHEEL (smoothing and coloring added).
The second Indus sign considered here is one I clumsily term LOOP ARMED MAN HOLDING SLASH, with a variant LOOP ARMED MAN HOLDING BACKSLASH (VI48).  It appears in all three of the lists: KP11, W2 and W23, and Fs A-5.  Fairservis declares it to be a man with an arrow, but gives its meaning as “mother, mother as a deity (?).”  This seems extraordinarily odd to me.  If it has female meaning, I should think it must represent a woman, not a man, and the object she is holding is more likely to be a baby than an arrow.  Bearing such a possible meaning in mind, compare the figurine which is holding a baby or small child, usually identified as a male but with nipples, reproduced at upper right ("bouncing baby blog").  It is a replica of an actual Harappan artifact.  Whatever the figurine really represents may be the model behind this Indus sign.
Wells gives the sign two designations, based on the side on which the diagonal stroke appears, with each one further subdivided into four variants (although his summary for W23 contradicts this by stating the number of variants to be only 1).  His W2 holds a backslash (i.e., diagonal stroke on the right in the actual inscriptions, which he reverses) totaling 49 occurrences: 33 from Mohenjo daro, including all four subtypes, “a,” “b,” “c,” and “d”; eight from Harappa, including “a” and “b”; three from Lothal, including “a” and “d”; three from Chanhujo daro including “b” and “c”; and two from Kalibangan including “c” and “d.”  I prefer to term these variants “Aa” through “Ad.”  His W23 holds a slash (i.e., actually a diagonal stroke on the left, reversed again in his list) totaling four occurrences: one from Mohenjo daro of “a”; and three from Lothal, described as “a,” “b” and “d,” which seems to leave no actual occurrences of “c.”  These I would term "Ba" to "Bc."  It is mostly the form of the upper half of the sign that varies, with only a minority having a clear anthropomorphic appearance.
To this rather unusual sign we may wish to compare the Old Chinese character nu3, which now means “girl, woman, female” (Wieger 1965: 169).  In the oldest form shown, the character is anthropomorphic but headless, with the arms hanging down and curved toward the center of the body.  Later, one arm essentially disappears, leaving an asymmetrical form.  The addition of strokes to represent breasts changes this to mu3, “mother” (1965: 171).


Proto-Elamite signs, from top: M127 and M099; at bottom, M123~d (cf. Indus
DOWN MAN ON BASE and LOOP ARMED MAN HOLDING SLASH).
 Proto-Elamite has a sign with some resemblance to the more anthropomorphic variants of the Indus sign (M123~d).  This seems to be a horizontal “man” with angular arms bent at the elbow, but without any object held.  A variant is quite different, however, changing the looping arms into a symmetrical triangle crossed by a straight line, with the “legs” very short (M123~ca).  The whole thing then more closely resembles an arrow than a person.


Seal Ns-5 with inscription: CARTWHEEL / BI-QUOTES / (over) STACKED SIX / FISH / POT /
ROUND HEADED MAN (detail, smoothing of image and color added).
The last Indus sign for this post is another variant of MAN given the further description ROUND HEAD (to be designated either MAN WITH ROUND HEAD or ROUND-HEADED MAN).  I enumerate it VI49 as the forty-ninth of the six-stroke signs.  Only Wells gives this type a separate listing, as W3c.  That is, it is the “c” variant of Wells’ MAN, although to my eyes it ought to be conflated with Wells’ “b” variant.  Wells states that there are 47 occurrences of the MAN in four variants, but does not specify the frequency of “c” variant.  I consider these to be L-4, K-16, B-1 (which also has feet), and Ns-5 (which is more like Wells’ “b”).  Wells shows VI49 to have an inverted triangular body in addition to the round head, which increases the stroke number.  And we could subdivide these further, since B-1 is small and K-16 tall, B-1 also set apart by its feet.

Chinese Old Seal writing from bronze votive object,
showing tian1 (second character from bottom on left).
This sign has many parallels around the world.  In Old Chinese, the deceased ancestor often appears in inscriptions with a rounded head and sometimes with a body thicker than a simple vertical line (Wieger 1965: 372, 367).  This character becomes tian1, discussed earlier.  Also in China, the NaXi proto-writing system makes use of an anthropomorphic symbol that typically has a round head, but stick limbs and body.
Proto-Elamite has a vaguely similar sign with a boxy “body” and triangular “head” (M320~f).  It also seems to have “feet.”

Proto-Elamite sign M320~f, which resembles an angular anthropomorph.

In the rock art of North America, there are often human-like figures with round heads and these frequently have thick bodies but stick limbs.  Such figures appear in Texas (e.g., Kirkland and Newcomb 1996: 177, Pl. 125, no. 2-C), in Arizona (e.g., Noble 1991: 62), and in Nevada and eastern California (e.g., Heizer and Baumhoff 1984: after 245, Pl. 20b; 294, fig. D-1n).  The last of these sources note 34 occurrences of anthropomorphic figures with semi-realistic heads and bodies but stick limbs (1984: 90). 
Schematic human figures from a "wampum belt" (Mohawk; redrawn from Appleton 1971: 18).

Similar figures occur in rock art elsewhere, both in Africa (e.g., Le Quellec 2004: 39, fig. 37 in the Wadi Sura of the Libyan desert; 71, fig. 22, in the shelter of Modjodje-Do in Mali; and 86-87, figs. 46 and 47 on the Pedra do Feitiço on the bank of the Zaire River) and in Australia (e.g., Flood 1997: 218, at Euriowia, western New South Wales; 219 at Mootwingee; and 220 in a rock shelter in Gunderbooks Range, Cobar region, western New South Wales).  In Australia this type of depiction is termed Simple Figurative.  It is variable in size (large and small), form (painting, drawing, and engraving), and date (from several thousand years old to considerably more recent) (1997: 220).  Large engravings and paintings tend to occur in the Sydney region, while small figures appear in the Cobar region.  Many, if not all, of both types (large and small figures), in Australia and Africa, are thought to have served ritual and religious functions in the societies of their creators.
It is very possible that the icons – the pictorial elements – on Indus seals and tablets also served a religious function.  That is, the people of the Indus Valley may have worshipped deities in the form of animals and, occasionally, human-animal hybrids.  Fairservis, on the other hand, sees the icons as representing social groups such as lineages or clans.  This is another possibility.  Most scholars in this field do not consider the inscriptions and icons to be related.  But, in the absence of decipherment, this point of view remains hypothetical, not proven.

ADDITIONAL REFERENCE:

Appleton, Le Roy H. 1971. American Indian Design and Decoration. New York: Dover (originally published 1950 by Chrles Scribner's Sons with the title Indian Art of the Americas).

Monday, January 3, 2011

Human Figures with an Additional Stroke

Seal M-304 with inscription: QUOTE UNDER MAN / DOUBLE FOOTED STOOLS / POTTED TWO / FISH / POT, and MAN lower right, below elephant and above tiger.  Note the icon of seated anthropomorphic figure with horns, often identified as the later Hindu god Shiva (watercolor with added color by author).

The first Indus sign for today’s discussion is QUOTE UNDER MAN (VI43).  There are not many occurrences of this sign, also known as KP14 and W19, in the Indus script.  It appears four times in all, three times at Mohenjo daro and once at Kalibangan.  As seen in my earlier post concerning the basic MAN (V23), simple anthropomorphic figures appear on virtually every continent, whether it is in writing, in proto-writing, or in art.  Adding a short vertical stroke below such a figure and between the legs is such a simple variation on the basic sign, one might expect to find many parallels to VI43.  In fact, though, such variation is not common at all. 

In Egyptian hieroglyphs, a single vertical stroke often appears below or beside a glyph to indicate that the marked glyph is ideographic, not phonetic.  However, while there is a seated man among the glyphs, there is no simple standing stick figure in the hieroglyphic script style, although a number of standing figures do appear.  As I noted in the earlier post on MAN, the most similar graphically of the hieroglyphs is the star (N14).  This glyph has the same five lines as the Indus MAN, but the star's “arms” angle upward instead of downward.  The star occurs below a curved line, half of the crescent moon glyph (N11) to form a ligatured glyph (N13).  This is ideographic in the word for a festival that was celebrated in the middle of the month.  This curve above a star (in Egypt) contains the same number of strokes as the quotation mark below a man (in South Asia), but the two look quite different in sum.
In Old Chinese, the Indus MAN is closely matchd by a representation of a man with his arms spread, da4, which means “big, great.”  This character does not combine with a single stroke beneath, but does combine with the numeral 10, a short-armed cross.  This forms the compound character tao1, “to advance, to move forward, to prosper rapidly, as the man who has past [sic] his tenth year” (Wieger 1965: 157).  A cross below a man not quite the same as a quotation mark, again, but the placement of the added element matches that of the QUOTE UNDER MAN.
Proto-Elamite sign M097~h resembling angular version of Indus QUOTE UNDER MAN.
Proto-Elamite provides the best parallel with a wedge-shaped impression placed between the "legs" of a human-like symbol that has a triangular “head” (M097~h).  As is typical of this proto-writing system, the symbol is positioned horizontally.  The basic “man” in this case probably does not represent a human, however, since it appears in texts that concern herds and flocks (Damerow and Englund 1989).

Hohokam engraving interpreted as a birth scene, with two anthropomorphs, one with a dot or two below the legs.

In the rock art of North America, there are many instances of an anthropomorphic figure with what seems to be a short tail.  This motif is somewhat similar to the Indus sign VI43, although the "quote" in the latter is usually shown in printed lists as detached from the "man."  The "men with tails" occur frequently in Texas (e.g., Newcomb 1996: 59, Pl. 21, no. 3; p. 74, Pl. 36, no. 3; p. 109, Pl. 69, no. 3; p. 149, Pl. 100, no. 8).  They also appear in Nevada (e.g., Heizer and Baumhoff 1984: 161, fig. 98c; 156, fig. 98e).  The illustration is found between these two states, in southern Arizona, made by people whose culture is termed Hohokam (Noble 1991: 65).  Where the “tail” is short on an American figure, it may indicate the male organ and not a tail at all.  Such motifs should then be interpreted as representing men, in the sense of male humans.  In other cases, the “tail” is longer and the figure may represent a lizard.  The same sort of motifs occur in the rock art of Africa, sometimes depicting humans and sometimes lizards (Le Quellec 2004: 72, fig. 24; p. 70, fig. 21; p. 131, fig. 44).

African painted motifs from the great overhang of Songo at Sanga, Mali.  Note the anthropomorph holding a tall staff compared to the lizard to the right of this, both outlined in white.

Another Indus sign based on a human-like stick figure is MAN HOLDING QUOTE (VI44).  In this sign, the basic MAN element occurs without a change in arm position, but with a stroke added attached to the end of one arm.  Elsewhere it is KP23, W13, and Fs A-12.  Fairservis calls this a man with his arm in a holding position (but not actually holding anything).  He thinks it represents an occupational suffix that is found in Dravidian languages.  In English, a similar occupational suffix still exists, –er as found in baker, writer, dancer, etc. 


Seal M-403 with inscription: MAN HOLDING QUOTE / SPEAR / LAMBDA / QUINT-FORK.
It is worth noting that Fairservis' definition is a problematic for the common hypothesis that the Indus seal inscriptions primarily include only names and occupations.  If that hypothesis is correct, then this “suffix” is astonishingly rare: Wells notes only eight occurrences.  Five are from Mohenjo daro, one from Harappa, two from Lothal.  I think there may be as many as 26, but that is still quite infrequent for such a handy suffix.
There are two main variants of this sign, “a” having the quote extend from the left “hand” of the MAN, “b” the reverse of this with the quote extending from the right “hand.”  In addition, some instances show this quote rising vertically while others show it at an angle.  In two of the occurrences, the “man” is missing his “head.”  In these two cases, the body and one leg are also a single vertical stroke, with the second “leg” descending at an angle.  This type ought to have its own designation, “c” (or given its own name and enumeration as a separate sign).
Egyptian hieroglyphs provide a number of examples of human and divine figures holding sticks or staffs, which may be taken as parallels.  One man holds his stick with both hands (A24), a second is leaning and using a single hand to hold his stick (A25).  Both are determinatives in words having to do with hitting, striking, and teaching.  Evidently, ancient Egyptian teachers motivated their students with the stick!  A third glyph depicts a man holding his stick up high in one hand (A59), a determinative in the word for “drive away.”  None of these provides a close match to the Indus sign.


Oracle bone variants of quan, "dog," above.  Below, modern character and Old Seal versions of quan, with Old Seal yu at the bottom. 
Old Chinese yields an interesting case where a character closely resembles the man with his arms out cited above, meaning "big," but means something utterly different.  In the modern character, quan3, “dog,” is identical to the word for “big” except that a short backslash is added over the right “arm” (Wieger 1967: 304).  This extra stroke is sometimes referred to as the dog's ear.  In the Old Seal script, what seem to be lower limbs (actually a leg and the tail?) form a curve, but the character looks even more like a little man holding a stick.  It is only in the earliest stage of writing on oracle bones that the character actually resembles a dog. 
Representations of a stick figure that may be holding a stick, tool, or weapon appear commonly in rock art.  Such motifs occur in many places in Africa (e.g., Le Quellec 2004: 39, 58, 60, 75, 86, 113, 123).  They are also to be found in North America (Newcomb 1996: 67, Pl.27, no. 3; 109, Pl. 69, no. 3).  In Africa, some variants of a motif resembling the “headless” Indus variant (“c”) also occur, but they represent cattle, not men (Le Quellec 2004: 126)!  Thus, the addition of a stroke to a symbol, as well as the removal of one, may be significant and meaningful in unpredictable ways.  This is a lesson to bear in mind when it comes to interpreting or deciphering the Indus symbols.

Schematic cattle painted at Bukoba, near Lake Nyanza, in Kenya, Africa.  The variant on lower left resembles the "headless" Indus MAN signs.

Broken seal M-1054 with partial inscription: CUPPED THREE / PINCH / MAN WITH SINGLE WING.
A third Indus sign involves the addition of a single stroke to the neck or shoulder of the basic anthropomorph.  In this case, I am not quite sure what to call it: MAN WITH SINGLE HORN (or MAN WITH SINGLE WING).  It is the forty-fifth of the six-stroke signs and thus VI45 in my list.  Fairservis does not show it, but it also appears as KP12 and as two signs in Wells, W38 and W65.  Wells distinguishes these two signs by adding a backslash to the left side of the “man” for W38, and a slash to the right side of the “man” in W65.  Each one is a singleton according to him.  I see more than that and I don’t reverse the signs on the seals as Wells does.  For me, variant “A” has a backslash on the left (M-1198 and H-347) while variant “B” has a slash on the right (M-1054, H-784, H-839). 

Oracle-bone variants of guo, "halberd," with ,modern variant at lower right, which resembles Indus MAN WITH SINGLE WING.

Old Chinese provides two characters that resemble that for “big,” modified by a stroke near the “arm” or “head.”  The first of these is yu2, which in Wieger’s imaginative description represents “a setter which s[c]ents the game, folds its ears...By extension, amazement, surprise, singular, extraordinary” (1965: 305).  The character does not much resemble a dog with an ear folded back, despite what Wieger says.  It looks like the “big” character with one “arm” bent back toward its “head” which is also bent.  The second character that resembles the Indus sign is not even animate: guo1, “a kind of halberd...A hook or crescent on the top, then a cross-bar, and a halter hanging” (1965: 177).  The modern form is now the 62nd radical and reminds me of a stick figure man.

Detail of yei with vertical head feathers from a Navaho blanket woven to replicate a sand painting (color added, not authentic).  Both arms are on one side here, indicating movement in that direction.  Other figures are shown with an arm on each side, more like the stance of the Indus sign.  Note also the medicine pouch hanging on one side like a "tail."

In North American rock art, anthropomorphic figures sometimes have a single prong rising from the head, a feature that may represent a feather in the hair (Heizer and Baumhoff 1984: 135, fig. 72a; Newcomb 1996: 53, Pl. 18, no. 5; cf. p. 47, Pl. 13, no. 3 with a penniform protuberance).  Supernatural beings called yeis appear routinely in Navaho sand paintings with a feather or another element on the head, sometimes shown rising up but more often shown perpendicular to the angle of head and body (Newcomb and Reichard 1975: Pl. XIV, showing perpendicular feathers on the heads of Holy Man, Holy Woman, Holy Boy, and Holy Girl; cf. Pl. XXIX, showing a tail between the legs and a triangular protuberance on the heads of Black Thunder and Blue Thunder).
The next Indus sign is TAILED MAN (VI46), another anthropomorph, this time apparently adorned with a laterally positioned tail.  It appears elsewhere as W40 only, where it is noted as a singleton from Mohenjo daro (M-234).  Because the actual sign appears just once, it could be an error for the basic MAN.  The seal carver might have made one groove for the left leg, then decided this was at the wrong angle and added another line, as a correction. 

Seal M-234 with inscription: CEE / SINGLE QUOTE / FISH UNDER CHEVRON / SPEAR / FAT EX / PINCH / FAT LAMBDA / POT // FOUR QUOTES / TAILED MAN / FAT STOOL / CAGED OVERLAPPING CIRCLES.
It is also possible that VI46 is just what it appears to be, perhaps a person wearing a tail or train as a costume or garment.  Parallels for such a practice do exist in other ancient societies.  For example, some Egyptian rites involved the king or a priest wearing an animal’s tail.  The ibis-headed god, Thoth, wears such an animal tail in The Book of Going Forth by Day: The Papyrus of Ani, better known as the Book of the Dead (Faulkner and Goelet 1994: 25, Pl. 3).  A priest performs rites for the deceased Ani, wearing a spotted leopard skin, complete with head, paws, and tail in a recurring image in many of the illustrations (e.g. 1994: 27, Pl. 3). 
In addition, this papyrus includes a plant with a human head, illustrating a passage wherein the deceased transforms into a lotus (1994: Pl. 28).  According to Goelet, the animal head represents an aspect of a particular Egyptian deity (1994: 144-145).  As such, these therianthropic images served the same function as fully anthropomorphic images of the same deities, in which the god’s attribute sits on the head like a hat.  Thus, the goddess Hathor appears in varied guises: “a cow with a solar disk between her horns, a slender woman with cow horns and solar disk upon her head, a woman with the [hieroglyphic] sign for ‘West’ upon her head...the menat-necklace and the head of a musical instrument known as the sistrum” (1994: 144).  Depending on which of these possibilities we might choose as a model, the Indus TAILED MAN might represent a human wearing a costume, a deity wearing the same as an identifier, an animal which has a tail (a monkey?), or a theriamorphic being -- part human, part animal.
In Mesopotamia, too, there are various representations of figures that combine human and animal features, including men dressed as fish (Black and Green 1992: 18, 83, 103, 108).  These represent the Seven Sages, wise men who lived before the Akkadian Flood (1992: 163).  The same civilizing figures also appear with human bodies, bird heads, and wings, in which guise they are known in modern literature as griffin-demons.  Other therianthropic beings from the same cultures include a bull-man, a scorpion-man, and eventually a lion-man, all with human heads and torsos but the back end of an animal; as well as a lion-demon, similar to the griffin-demon but with a leonine head.  There is also a lion-centaur, a creature with a human head and torso attached to the full body of a lion – with front and back leonine legs – and sometimes with wings (1992: 120). 

 Mesopotamian bull-man (image drawn from cylinder seal by author).
The last being recalls the Egyptian deity Tutu, “one who keeps enemies at a distance,” which has a human head on the body of a dog or lion (Pinch 1994: 38).  The Great Sphinx is a similar image on a far larger scale, originally representing the pharaoh Khufu or Kephren.  One type of soul in Egyptian imagery is the ba, shown human-headed and sometimes possessing human arms as well, but with the body of a bird (1994: 159).  This aspect of the soul is also a hieroglyph (G53), an ideograph in the word b3, “soul” (the main other aspect of the soul is the ka, written with the glyph of two raised arms).

Small sphinx from ancient Egypt.

Various cultures worldwide have produced depictions of other beings that are part human, part animal.  Sometimes these are gods, as in Egypt where many deities appear as anthropomorphs with animal heads (e.g., Pinch 1994: 27, ibis-headed Thoth; 31, jackal (?) headed Seth; 34, dog-headed Anubis, falcon-headed Horus, etc.).  In other places, such as southern Africa, animal-headed anthropomorphs have often been interpreted as shamans (Lewis-Williams 2004). 

Seal Ns-9 from Nausharo, with icon of apparent therianthrope, part tiger, part woman.

On Indus seals, one of the least frequent icons represents a being that is part human and part tiger (M-311, K-50, K-65, Ns-9).  This creature has long horns matching those of the markhor (a type of goat).  Rising from the anthropomorphic head, between these horns, there is a plant-like motif.  The creature has a fully anthropomorphic head and body in front, at the back of which is the long, striped body and back end of a tiger.  There seems to be long pigtail stretching out from the back of the head and over the tiger portion of the figure.  Also, the human element apparently wears a long skirt.  This garment and the long hair may indicate that this being is female, a rare feature among Indus icons.  The other animals and imaginary beasts (the human-faced markhor, the three-headed bovine, etc.) are decidedly male.  I consider it within the realm of possibility, then, that the TAILED MAN sign is actually meant to have a tail as an abbreviated form of the “tiger woman.”
It is difficult to find a precise match for this sign in any other arena.  However, in Old Chinese, an additional stroke changes the meaning of a basic character in various ways, depending on where the stroke occurs.  The character for the dog becomes ba2 when an oblique stroke crosses the leg, meaning “a dog led in a leash, by a string tied up to a leg, according to the Chinese way” (Wieger 1965: 304).  Another character, this time for a woman (which, interestingly enough, lacks a head) becomes wu2 when crossed by a horizontal stroke.  This means “a woman placed under lock and key...for misbehaviour....to avoid, to abstain, inutility, nothingness” (1965: 170).
In North America, it is easy to find anthropomorphic figures with horns and others (which may actually be lizards) with tails of various lengths.  In the corpus from Nevada and eastern California, there are 485 representations of anthropomorphs, divided by the authors into six categories, and 11 “lizards,” which resemble stick figures of “humans” except in their proportions (Heizer and Baumhoff 1984: 86-91).  The authors are more confident than I am that a modern viewer can clearly distinguish between “lizards” and human stick figures.  They define the lizard as having a long tail and short limbs while the stick figures of people have longer limbs and short "tails" (or none).  But I see every gradation between what I would characterize as long and short in tails and in limbs!  Even among the “katchinas” (a highly stylized anthropomorph), which are certainly not lizards, I see at least one that has both horns and a tail (1984: 118, fig. 65a, 2nd figure from left).  The figures with both features, then, may be therianthropes.

Rock painting in the Beersheba region, later moved to Bloemfontein Museum, South Africa.  Therianthropic figures which might be interpreted by Westerners as shamans (with bird wings and eland heads, but human bodies, possibly with tails), but interpreted by San informants as people changing into frogs (detail painted by author based on Le Quellec 2004: 205).
In the rock art of southern Africa, a number of images of therianthropes have become relatively famous through the work of scholars proposing a shamanic interpretation (e.g., Lewis-Williams 2002: color plate 9 after 112; ch. 5, 136-162).  The most common such depiction shows a creature with the head of an antelope, especially that of an eland, and a human body.  Figures with tails, one or more prongs protruding from the head, and short strokes descending from widespread arms – closely resembling North American thunderbird images – are said to be winged shamans (2002: 150).  The same or similar animal-headed (or “winged”) humans appear with other interpretations – people wearing animal headdresses, spirits of the dead, therianthropic ancestors (Le Quellec 2004: 168-205).
Australia also provides examples of rock art depicting beings that may combine human and animal features.  One such figure may represent a lizard, in a painting from Endaen shelter, Stanley Island, Princess Charlotte Bay (Layton 1992: 7).  The apparent limbs are perpendicular to what seems to be the body, and the “tail” is relatively long, expected in lizard depictions.  But there is an additional diagonal stroke near one end (the head or the tail?) that is quite enigmatic.  A painting made in recent times for magical purposes appears to have a human body, a tail, and perhaps an animal head (by John Flinders Wodhyethi c. 1920, on Ngurromo, Clack Island, Princess Charlotte Bay; 1992: 26). 

In Dandani cave, there is a row of anthropomorphic figures joined by their outspread arms, most of which seem to have a short tail (1992: 61).  The author describes this as men dancing.  Another group of similar figures in the same cave shows no “tails” of this sort, a group appearing beneath the extended arm and hooked boomerang of a larger “tailed” person.  One explanation provided by local people for this group is that the larger figure depicts an infamous murderer and the smaller figures his victims (1992: 125).  I find myself wondering what it is that indicates dancing in the first group, but no dancing in the second.

An anthropomorph with four digits on each hand is painted above a presumed Rainbow Serpent at Twin Falls Creek, western Arnhem Land (1992: 162).  This elongated stick figure has three extensions from the head, one sticking up, one to the right, and one to the left.  Is it therianthropic, or are the extensions from the head representations of something physical -- decorative items in the hair?   How can one ever be sure? 
To his credit, Layton discusses at length the difficulty of clearly distinguishing anthropomorphs from zoomorphs, as well as distinguishing among the animals in the latter category (1992: 168-182).  For example, a single motif resembling the Chinese “big” character, but with a “V”-shaped “head,” has been interpreted variously as a man, a squid, or a shark with open mouth; the same figure with a short “tail” may again be a man, unless it is a beche de mer, a crayfish, or a very thin turtle (1992: 175)!  This should serve as a reminder that modern interpreters of art and symbol cannot be certain of their conclusions, especially in the absence of a living tradition.

REFERENCES:
Black, Jeremy and Anthony Green. 1992. Gods, Demons and Symbols of Ancient Mesopotamia: An Illustrated Dictionary. Austin: University of Texas .
Damerow, Peter and Robert Englund. 1989. The Proto-Elamite Texts from Tepe Yahya. Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University.
Faulkner, Raymond O. and Ogden Goelet. 1994. The Egyptian Book of the Dead: The Book of Going Forth by Day. San Francisco: Chronicle Books.
Heizer, Robert and Martin Baumhoff. 1984. Prehistoric Rock Art of Nevada and Eastern California. Berkeley: University of California.
Joshi, Jagat Pati and Asko Parpola. 1987. Corpus of Indus Seals and Inscriptions. 1. Collections in India. Helsinki: Suomalainen Tiedeakatemia.
Kirkland, Forrest and text by W.W. Newcomb, Jr. 1996. The Rock Art of Texas Indians. Austin: University of Texas.
Layton, Robert. 1992. Australian Rock Art: A New Synthesis. Cambridge University.
Le Quellec, Jean-Loic. 2004. Rock Art in Africa: Mythology and Legend. Transl. Paul Bahn. Paris: Flammarion.
Lewis-Williams, David. 2002. The Mind in the Cave: Consciousness and the Origins of Art. London: Thames & Hudson.
Newcomb, Franc, with text by Gladys Reichard. 1975. Sandpaintings of the Navajo Shooting Chant. New York: Dover. (Originally published 1937 by J.J. Augustin, New York).
Noble, David Grant. 1991. The Hohokam: Ancient People of the Desert. Santa Fe, New Mexico: School of American Research.
Pinch, Geraldine. 1994 & 2006. Magic in Ancient Egypt. London: The British Museum.
Shah, Sayid Ghulam Mustafa and Asko Parpola. 1991. Corpus of Indus Seals and Inscriptions. 2. Collections in Pakistan. Helsinki: Suomalainen Tiedeakatemia.